Re:Jury foreman says Apple patents valid due to different pr...
by papercrane on Wednesday August 29, 2012 @09:12AM
(#4448318)
Claim 1 is for a system with tv tuner, internal hardrive and a removable media. So it is slightly different then a Tivo.
Although I don't think taking a Tivo and slapping a CD writer on it should be eligible for a patent. Especially if TV tuners where available at retail at the time (pretty sure they were, but I have no evidence of that.) Basically anybody that put a TV tuner into a computer with a CD writer is prior art for claim 1.
Re:Jury foreman says Apple patents valid due to different pr...
by jhaglund on Thursday August 30, 2012 @12:49AM
(#4453028)
Pretty sure I wanted an analog tuner/video VLB-card in the 90s. Couldn't afford one, but I imagine the people who bought them, did this stuff with them.
Although I don't think taking a Tivo and slapping a CD writer on it should be eligible for a patent. Especially if TV tuners where available at retail at the time (pretty sure they were, but I have no evidence of that.) Basically anybody that put a TV tuner into a computer with a CD writer is prior art for claim 1.