Re:July 5, 1687: When Newton Explained Why You Don't Float Away
by nilamo on Sunday July 06, 2025 @08:12AM
(#44480070)
Is that how all "science" was written? It's nearly unreadable, the plot (Spirit?) lost in the language.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:July 5, 1687: When Newton Explained Why You Don't Float Away
by analog31 on Sunday July 06, 2025 @10:55AM
(#44481284)
In some sense, yes. I've seen portions of works by people like Newton etc. You had to be a philosopher to read them, much less understand them. In a lot of cases, the same "material" that we learn today required someone to come along later and work out a notation that we can read and teach. My favorite example is the Algebra of Al-Khwarizmi, which contained no numbers, much less equations, but was just a wall of text. In fact, equations were invented later. Also, I think the electromagnetism of Maxwell was reformulated into the equations that we love and cherish by Heaviside.
Re:July 5, 1687: When Newton Explained Why You Don't Float Away
by dr_dshiv on Sunday July 06, 2025 @02:11PM
(#44482811)
The principa and the scholium were written in NeoLatin, the version of Latin adopted from the Renaissance through the 1900s to write scientific, philosophical and other treatises
Re:July 5, 1687: When Newton Explained Why You Don't Float Away
by chowells on Sunday July 06, 2025 @04:14PM
(#44483670)
It's how a lot of science was written, and knowing that makes strong Sapir-Whorf a really funny joke. We didn't derive our ideas about science from our language. Developing our ideas of science shaped our language so it could communicate them efficiently.
(Weak Sapir-Whorf is still a perfectly fine observation, but it's a lot less predictive as a hypothesis.)