News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Operators, Not Users and Programmers by chubot on Saturday July 05, 2025 @11:43PM (#44477651)
I like this framing! Personally, I'd like to see the Unix shell evolve into a system with a GUI. Where text and graphics are integrated, and the shell isn't "trapped" in the terminal.

There is a historical, path-dependent conflation in this area -- a text-based UI doesn't necessarily imply a terminal-based UI

Some links to work in that direction: https://www.oilshell.org/blog/2023/12/screencasts.html#headl...

Excel is pretty good at combining the two paradigms -- it has the textbox where you can type (almost like a URL bar), and it has the GUI part. But for all its power, I don't want to Excel ... I like spreadsheets, and use LibreCalc a bit, though it's limited.

And I'd like if there were multiple GUI/graphical paradigms combined with text, not just the grid of cells (as useful as it is)

Re:Operators, Not Users and Programmers by chaboud on Saturday July 05, 2025 @11:55PM (#44477695)
AutoCAD is kind of a classic form of integration of text with GUI via a command window. In general, any GUI I build these days I build to be scriptable, if possible, and I look to translate as much as possible through that scriptable interface.

This has helped immensely with AI assistive (“vibe coding”) tools.

Re:Operators, Not Users and Programmers by jynelson on Sunday July 06, 2025 @02:51AM (#44478429)
yes!!! this is exactly the direction i want to go with the post on “terminal of the future”—we should reimagine a structured terminal, where the interface isn’t dependent on emulating a VT100.

have you seen https://www.warp.dev/modern-terminal? they’ve made really a lot of progress here, they just locked it all in a platform and then didn’t have the vision to let you metaprogram it.

Re:Operators, Not Users and Programmers by chubot on Monday July 07, 2025 @12:19AM (#44486722)
I'll keep an eye out for the blog post!

We're still working (intermittently) on a better shell <-> terminal interface. We actually did the first demo back in 2021, before we became aware of Warp. And here is an update from a month ago, which mentions Warp / IntelliJ / VSCode:

https://lobste.rs/s/viwe6p/open_source_can_t_coordinate#c_px...

That is, we did some demos with a nushell contributor, to see if there is a protocol that Oils and nushell can agree on. The big constraints seems to be bash and zsh. (I still believe in graceful evolution, not building a "inner platform")

I think these 2025 demos went pretty well, but it's still in the demo/research phase.

After working in this area for many years, I think the bottleneck is coordination, mentioned here - https://lobste.rs/s/ejcoud/dreaming_smel_shell

i.e. there are many separate projects doing similar things, and most of them get to 80% or so. I like that you mention a lot of prior art!

More links: https://github.com/oils-for-unix/oils/wiki/Headless-Shell-Pr...

Feel free to join any of the Zulip discussions ... there are a bunch of prototypes floating around, but nothing set in stone!