News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by sherdil2022 on Saturday July 05, 2025 @10:22PM (#44477292)
“AI or not” is going to be the norm going forward. It already is in many areas and services.

Sad state of affairs for creatives and non-creatives alike.

Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by echelon on Saturday July 05, 2025 @10:29PM (#44477335)
> “AI or not” is going to be the norm going forward

The new "is it Photoshop?"

It'll be so pervasive that the average Instagram user will become fluent.

People are going to get so used to this technology. It's going to be added to everything.

> Sad state of affairs for creatives and non-creatives alike.

Heavy disagree. I absolutely love AI generated content, and my friends and I have been using the tools quite a bit:

https://youtu.be/Tii9uF0nAx4

https://youtu.be/tAAiiKteM-U

https://youtu.be/H4NFXGMuwpY

Other people are making really cool stuff, too.

Hollywood never catered to what I wanted. We lived in a drought where 20,000 yearly film students had to fight for 100 roles of autonomy (most often won by nepotism). I certainly never made it, despite trying. Now I can make the stuff I want to see for myself.

Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by 0xfaded on Saturday July 05, 2025 @11:27PM (#44477581)
It seems, though I have no way of knowing, that these clips were conceived by a human and realized using AI tools.

How would you feel if these were presented amongst a sea of other clips that were prompted by "create a short video that captures the attention of a 25-30yo male", presumably in the hope of syphoning a few cents from Instagram?

I recently bought a book to read on a flight, and it was the first time it occured to me there was no way to verify the thing was written by a human other than to check that it was published before ~2023. Part of what I, at least, feel when reading a book is a connection to another human and our shared experience that lead them to tell their story. For me this experience is steeply cheapened by the thought that that connection might not be with a human.

I feel similarly about the Ghibli style transfer craze. AI generated images may be "cool", but you no longer know if you're connecting to an artist. At least in the case of Ghibli, their work is well known so it's possible to tell. Where's the room for human creatives to create new original art styles? The rightful default assumption is that anything post 2023 came out of a model as some mash-up of inputs stolen from anonymous no-names.

FWIW, this is coming from a non-creative atheist who has long belived humans are nothing more than probabilistic biological machines.

Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by userbinator on Sunday July 06, 2025 @02:06AM (#44478227)
Keep in mind that even with AI-generated content, a human ultimately came up with the idea and told the AI to do it.
Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by pona-a on Sunday July 06, 2025 @04:15AM (#44478797)
[delayed]
Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by urbandw311er on Sunday July 06, 2025 @04:48AM (#44478965)
And the thousands of other unpaid humans who came up with the ideas and creative content in the training data.
Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by SoftTalker on Saturday July 05, 2025 @10:34PM (#44477363)
I think it's cool if you're making something for yourself.

Not cool if you're a media corporation generating something, slapping DRM on it, and trying to pass it off as the work of real human artists so that they don't have to pay real human artists.

Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by aspenmayer on Saturday July 05, 2025 @10:57PM (#44477460)
You don’t have to buy products that aren’t certified-AI-free. You’re not obligated to buy many things, though existing without expenditure is more of a life goal and less of a realistic expectation.
Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by SoftTalker on Sunday July 06, 2025 @12:07AM (#44477746)
I would never knowingly pay money for any "work of art" created by AI.
Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by echelon on Sunday July 06, 2025 @12:46AM (#44477915)
Let's see how this claim fares in 10 years.
Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by aspenmayer on Sunday July 06, 2025 @01:10AM (#44478010)
That is a perfectly reasonable position to hold.

Would you feel defrauded to find out that you had knowingly paid money for a “work of art” created by AI, if you have previously found it to your satisfaction?

I tend to not care too much myself. I trust my own sense of taste. If I enjoy content, I probably won’t care if AI made it, though I’ll admit a pro-human bias, because humans are capable of suffering and lack. Part of being pro-human for me is being fine with others using tools and techniques to reduce effort and especially drudgery.

I still use spellcheck. I don’t use dictation tools or read aloud tools, but I am human and I struggle like anyone else to exert myself. I just don’t require assistance to do those things right now, but I know that may change at a moment’s notice. Though I don’t “need” assistive technology or devices presently, I still enjoy and prefer subtitles even now.

If you need to use tools to consume or produce, I won’t look down on you. Just be honest about it. If you used AI to make something, just say so. It’s not a personal failing to use AI tools, but it is a failing to use them and then lie about it.

Photojournalists know what I mean, as they can do in-camera techniques as long as it isn’t misrepresenting how a scene appears to a person basically, whereas most post-processing techniques are not really considered in comporting with professional ethics because representation of reality is the aim and goal, not making aesthetic decisions or staging photos as if they are naturalistic, but documenting actual events that transpired independently of the people capturing the events on camera.

But there’s a point where what we have doesn’t have enough cooks in the kitchen, as silly as that sounds. AI generated subtitles are often wrong, and there’s no way as a human who is reading them to suggest corrections on most platforms. Now we have AI automated dubbing, which I have only used a few times. It seems mostly fine, but I don’t think failures are as obvious in that case if I don’t speak the source language, so I guess I’m mostly speaking of closed captions or subtitles in languages I speak, since other errors I wouldn’t notice to begin with, such as errors in translation.

How much art isn’t being made til now, not for lack of will, drive, desire, or grit, but inability to develop skills and taste because they don’t have arms, literally or metaphorically. Isn’t it a bit like gatekeeping art to say that art made by AI isn’t a true work of art? AI tools aren’t self-directed or self-aware. There is a human involved somewhere, and they are a patron of the arts at the very least, if not an editor. I view the human in the loop as legitimate an artist as Andy Warhol at his height of production capacity. He didn’t even make art. He made decisions about what art is once he saw it in the world. His art was recontextualization. AI is just going through the looking glass.

So it goes. Same as it ever was? Wasn’t it ever thus? Art is for us by us, but that’s not a given. I didn’t make the flower I admire, either, nor the apple of my eye.

Don’t let anything steal your joy, even you and your own preconceived notions of what joy ought be caused by, or you’re just raining on your own parade and those of others, or becoming an old person shaking their fist at a cloud. We’re making rainbows if you’d just wait.

Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by satvikpendem on Sunday July 06, 2025 @12:44AM (#44477904)
Lots of jobs in the past have been obviated away from technological advances, there is no difference in this current generation of jobs either. No one still thinks of the farrier when talking about cars (and even then, farriers still exist).
Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by badsectoracula on Sunday July 06, 2025 @02:01AM (#44478197)
Considering the discussion, IMO that one feels more relevant:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tj-dJvGVb-w

(i loved those videos btw)