Re:Websites hosting major US climate reports taken down
by cosmicgadget on Thursday July 03, 2025 @10:56AM
(#44455716)
Journals remove papers that break rules, e.g. fabricating data or boning your postdocs. You seem to be waving at all of climate science and saying they all fail the same scrutiny. And you use the vaguest possible accusation: "they have bias", something that could be said or every scientific paper.
Re:Websites hosting major US climate reports taken down
by zmgsabst on Thursday July 03, 2025 @09:37PM
(#44460459)
I’m not making any claim, but it’s clear the people accused of removing them feel the bias delegitimizes the results — so the OP’s logic is incorrect. As I originally said.
Also, factually, they’re merely transferring the website to a different department, so this whole argument is moot.
Re:Websites hosting major US climate reports taken down
by cosmicgadget on Thursday July 03, 2025 @10:26PM
(#44460651)
I hope it's true that the hosting duties are simply passed to NASA. Surely you've seen enough in the past six months to not assume the stated plan is their actual intention.
Re:Websites hosting major US climate reports taken down
by Hnrobert42 on Sunday July 06, 2025 @11:25AM
(#44481539)
Yeah. I thought about that difference (inst vs SM), but I figured it was cancelled out by the fact that scientific research is way more rigorous than a tweet no matter how you slice it.
If you believe they’re biased, removing them is removing false legitimacy from biased content — something the government has an interest in. And no different than a journal retracting a flawed paper.
And since you want to discuss “fair argument”: there’s an obvious difference between allowing discourse on a public forum and publishing as an institution.