These days, I just turn on the MAC address filter that's built in to most wifi base stations. Now, unless I've manually entered your MAC address into my whitelist, my router won't connect you. My wifi shows up as "open" to any machine that passes by, yet it won't connect.
Many (most?) of you know more about security than I do. How secure is the MAC address whitelist approach compared to a password approach?
* WPA2 hasn't been 'cracked' * Without 'passwording', all your traffic is unencrypted and can be trivially sniffed * Spoofing one of your whitelisted MAC addresses in order to use your network is easy
1) I would define something as "not cracked" if it is as strong as its password--in other words, there's no way to circumvent it that isn't a general vulnerability (peek through my window, get a keylogger on my machine, etc.) I assume you're telling me that this is the case with WPA2.
2) It sounds as though you are saying that something like WPA2 doesn't just authenticate a login but remains in use as an encryption key for subsequent wireless data interchange between client and base station. If I'm understanding correctly, that's a powerful point.
3) I knew that MAC addresses could be spoofed, but I was thinking they wouldn't know WHICH MAC address to pretend to have. Of course, if I'd been a little smarter, I would have noticed that my own linux process was using the MAC address a client claimed to have to throw out unrecognized machines (before I had MAC address filtering as a built-in router feature). If they were sending their MAC address to me, then my own client machine would be sending its MAC address in clear text to them, telling them which MAC address to pretend to have. Duh.
Well, I feel a little dumber and a little smarter. Time to go change my network. Thanks again.
Since you said your WiFi is open, the only thing that needs to be done is fire up the aircrack-ng airdump and sniff, there I would see your MAC, in the clear. Then I could set my own to it or select any other mac I have seen connecting to for a longer while ,and use it and access your router and add my other mac on its whitelist.
Isn't that true of WPA and WPA2 though also?
There are precomputed rainbow tables of common SSID+passphrase combinations floating around, but as a general rule, WPA2 with a sufficiently complex passphrase should be secure against anyone who doesn't have a massive compute cluster at their disposal.
He would have to be very bored indeed. Singling out my home to spend considerable time at an inconvenient in-range location to crack passwords to access ... what, exactly? view pictures of my toddlers? copy my slightly deranged music collection? If he's looking for free network access, he can go down the street and get it from McDonalds or Starbucks or wherever while sitting in a comfortable chair sipping a soda.
I realize a bored teen is different from a SWAT team. Both, however, would need unusual motivation to turn their talents on my abode.
Whereas a bored teenage neighbor could attack your wireless network with a very small chance of being detected. Or with a sensitive directional antenna it doesn't even have to be your neighbor if the goal is just to sniff traffic. Plus, the only cost to you in defending against this attack is entering a more complex password on new devices. Stick a note on the fridge or choose a phrase.