News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Sad State of the Startup Pitch by jandrewrogers on Tuesday August 28, 2012 @12:46PM (#4444589)
This is just a case of the pendulum swinging too far in the opposite direction.

I remember when early stage startups were expected to have elaborate 20-page business plans, detailed financial projections going out 5 years, and countless powerpoints of market positioning and fit. It was all bullshit but you were expected to do it.

Over time, that exercise in fiction loosened up. Investors became more interested in if you really understood your product, your market, and what it was going to take to bring your product to that market. Demonstrations of sufficient competency, adaptivity, and intelligence were required but investors only demanded documentation of things you could actually say something meaningful about.

Somewhere along the way, more VCs became obsessed with shiny clicky demos (nominally, "product") above all else, often to the exclusion of any substantial discussion of the actual business and market strategy. This demo obsession is a form of mitigating execution risk but it is far from the only kind of risk in a startup and often the other risks are being ignored when this happens. The startup world is a market, supply and demand. Wannabe startups are providing what many VCs are demanding; Bryce may or may not be one of the VCs encouraging it but he swims in a market where many VCs are. Many people who should not be doing a startup think they can because plenty of VCs will actually consider their half-assed ideas.

It falls on both the VCs and startup founders. VCs need to stop acting as though a shiny demo trumps all other funding considerations and startup founders need to stop acting as though you can put serious effort into the business parts later as long as you have a vague idea and a shiny demo.

There are no comments on this comment yet.