Some people care more about getting exactly the right thing, even if the value proposition is weaker. They'll pay significantly more for apparently trivial differences, because they don't want to buy something they're not happy with; they're spending money anyway and why put up with something they don't want if they can afford something they do want?
Neither of these people are strictly unreasonable.
Lots of smart people get hooked onto extremely specific solutions that aren't even improvements.
I saw it in software development with many things (VIPER and SwiftUI both reduce development velocity compared to MVC and old-school Interface Builder); I've seen it with Musk trying to do tunnels even when roads would be cheaper and safer; there's also (infamously) Juicero; and in the UK in the 80s there was the Sinclair C5.
That said, is this really an example of that?
Myself, I barely use my electric barbecue, so I don't know the best way to clean things (it's not yet become dirty enough to bother cleaning). But I have seen the brushes he's complaining about, and I have not previously considered using tinfoil, so it's not a completely crazy idea that people might want a better brush.
Look, I love Destin, watch all his stuff recommend it all the time.
But I'm never going to buy this product, it's just too expensive for what it does compared to the alternatives.
And I know he knows that. He's clearly at least 'not stupid'.
So something isn't squaring with this.