Re:There Are No New Ideas in AI Only New Datasets
by nomel on Monday June 30, 2025 @03:54PM
(#44427149)
There are many people who mentally developed while paralyzed that literally drive around their bodies via motorized wheelchair. I don't think there's any evidence that a brain couldn't exist or develop in a jar, given only the inputs modern AI now has (text, video, audio).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:There Are No New Ideas in AI Only New Datasets
by Swizec on Monday June 30, 2025 @04:26PM
(#44427467)
> any evidence that a brain couldn't exist or develop in a jar
The brain could. Of course it could. It's just a signals processing machine.
But would it be missing anything we consider core to the way humans think? Would it struggle with parts of cognition?
For example: experiments were done with cats growing up in environments with vertical lines only. They were then put in a normal room and had a hard time understanding flat surfaces.
https://computervisionblog.wordpress.com/2013/06/01/cats-and...
Re:There Are No New Ideas in AI Only New Datasets
by nomel on Monday June 30, 2025 @04:57PM
(#44427797)
This isn't remotely a hypothetical, so I imagine there are some examples out there, especially from back when polio was a problem. Although, for practical reasons, they might have had limited exposure to novelty, which could have negative consequences.
Re:There Are No New Ideas in AI Only New Datasets
by Swizec on Monday June 30, 2025 @10:22PM
(#44429994)
I agree it’s not hypothetical and also as a layperson I don’t know how much impact on cognition has been studied. Would be cool if it has!
I do know of studies that showed blind people start using their visual cortex to process sounds. That is pretty cool imo