At some point, as a manager, you put your own career/reputation on the line.
It is important to remember we are discussing outliers here. 4s & 5s represent 20% of the company. My blog post does not impact that other 80% really at all, and within the 20%, 7% likely really deserve to be let go anyway (IMO).
It's a big company. With any sufficiently large population there will be problems. I'm not a MS apologist, but at the same time MS produces some pretty damn good things regardless.
From the stories I've heard from friends at MS, there does really seem to be a sense of office-politics-gone-insane there.
At some point, it seems there has to be a backlash.