News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FAA to reevaluate inflight portable electronic device use by bdunn on Monday August 27, 2012 @10:48PM (#4441890)
From what I've heard, it's more to try to keep distractions to a minimum during high risk parts of flight - namely, take off and landing. But still being able to read a magazine but not a Kindle negates this whole arguments.

Trust me: if there was a technical risk from iPhones, they wouldn't be allowed onboard.

Re:FAA to reevaluate inflight portable electronic device use by frisco on Monday August 27, 2012 @11:24PM (#4441978)
If by "high risk" you mean, "orders of magnitude safer than any other common mode of transportation". (Flying having ~3 deaths per 10 billion passenger miles, with driving at ~1.6 deaths per hundred million passenger miles.)

Early on, EM radiation could have interfered with old-school VOR navigation. However, today everyone uses GPS navigation, and planes are huge flying EM-emitting computers anyway, so this is no longer a real issue. Communications are interference tolerant for the kinds of emissions we're talking about.

The explanation I'd heard for why the no-phones-in-flight rule is still around is that passengers really dislike people having cell phone conversations next to them. Thus, the airlines can provide a better customer experience by keeping phones off. This obviously doesn't extend to no electronics at take-off or landing, of course, which should just be allowed.

Re:FAA to reevaluate inflight portable electronic device use by bdunn on Tuesday August 28, 2012 @07:33AM (#4443113)
Agreed. As a (private) pilot, and I understand why getting the passengers and crew focused for take off and landing is important. Compared to normal flight, those are the riskiest times - though as you said, still extremely safe compared to driving.

I understand the no-phones rule. I actually love that cell phones being used to TALK ON aren't allowed in flight. What I take issue with is that having electronics on is a safety hazard to the aircraft. If that was true, my Kindle would be confiscated along with my > 3.1oz bottle of shampoo at the checkpoint.

Re:FAA to reevaluate inflight portable electronic device use by munin on Tuesday August 28, 2012 @12:36AM (#4442146)
these are the same air carriers that flew planes into the ground until the FAA mandated they have GPWS[1], so I don't think the "if they honestly posed a risk we would do something about it". people have taken bigger risks with life-safety technology that has demonstrated to cause crashes or take hundreds of lives before...

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrain_awareness_warning_syste...