News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Look at yourself objectively by nl on Monday August 27, 2012 @10:02PM (#4441791)
So he was obviously right.

Not at all. Semmelweis thought something associated with death was what was killing people (eg, he chose chlorinated limes which he found best removed the stink of death).

I suspect the focus on death and dead people meant people focused on that, and "proved" to themselves he was "wrong".

I can imagine scenarios where doctors dealt with one woman who had a good birth experience, didn't use the Semmelweis handwashing method (because the first woman didn't have the death particles) and then the next woman got infected and died. To many (unfortunately), that would prove his theory was wrong.

Re:Look at yourself objectively by acqq on Tuesday August 28, 2012 @01:48AM (#4442332)
Citation needed, since you claim that doctors actually used the results of experiments to disprove him but at the same time didn't heed to the results of the experiments that showed that using lime was obviously beneficial.
Re:Look at yourself objectively by nl on Tuesday August 28, 2012 @08:40PM (#4446560)
Citation needed

No it isn't.

you claim

No I didn't. I was very careful to make clear this was my opinion only ("I suspect" and "I can imagine scenarios").

As I noted, lime wasn't obviously beneficial, because Semmelweis claimed it removed the "cadaveric particles", and yet people were still dying when there should have been no "cadaveric particles" around (ie, no one had died).

It's like the story of how scurvy started happening again in the early 20th century with Scott in the Antarctic[1]. In the 18th century scurvy had been defeated by drinking (fresh) lime juice on long sea voyages, without a correct understanding of the mechanisms involved.

Read the linked article about how it happened.

[1] http://idlewords.com/2010/03/scott_and_scurvy.htm