Re:Got a 4? You just got fired from Microsoft
by homosaur on Monday August 27, 2012 @09:38PM
(#4441733)
What would Ballmer rate in CEO stack ranking with the rest of corporate America?
Re:Got a 4? You just got fired from Microsoft
by alttag on Monday August 27, 2012 @10:46PM
(#4441884)
True, many things, including strategic focus and market selection, can lead to success or failure, but certainly HR policies have some effect in favoring/repressing innovation, collaboration, and truth to power.
Re:Got a 4? You just got fired from Microsoft
by michaelochurch on Monday August 27, 2012 @10:36PM
(#4441857)
Stack ranking and vicious careerism can demolish a company independent of anything else. Look at what is happening to Google, with its calibration score nonsense and the draconian transfer policy. Same story, 7 years back in time.
"Vision" is one thing but a lot of people have vision (or think they do). Very few people have that rare combination of interpersonal empathy and competency around complexity that enable them to reliably make good decisions as executives of large companies. (Worse yet, over 90 percent of the people given those positions get them as favors and utterly lack both skill sets.)
Likewise, I wouldn't give it much credit if MS (or Google, or whoever) does well. With a few notable counterexamples, most very large companies end up adopting processes to manage the size of the company, but how large is the impact of the particular process chosen? Is it really controlling success or failure?
Bad management/vision can happen in any system.