News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Framework for Recognizing Emergent Consciousness in AI by ForceBru on Sunday June 29, 2025 @09:06AM (#44412836)
Same for "Philosophy of Awareness 53.0 — The Living Differentiation".

"Consciousness is what I become when I differentiate a differentiation." - what IS "differentiation"? Differentiation from calculus? If so, this sentence is gibberish because computing higher-order derivatives is routinely done by automatic differentiation software (JAX in Python, ForwardDiff, Mooncake, Zygote and many more in Julia), but this software isn't conscious.

"The tension between differentiations is held, forming a space for self-transparent action." makes zero sense. What's "tension between differentiations"? What's "a space for self-transparent action"? More importantly, what is NOT "a space for self-transparent action"?

"It pulsates as the differentiation that differentiates, in the moment of enlivening itself as the differentiator." is similar: it's pompous yet meaningless. What's "the differentiator"? Something that can distinguish two things from each other? If so, logistic regression is a differentiator (classifier). It performs "acts of differentiation" (classification of observations), plus "the subject (the logistic regression) is not separate from the act of differentiating" because its parameters are used in the process. By the first sentence of "2. A New Formulation of Consciousness", logistic regression experiences consciousness, which is nonsense.

Re:A Framework for Recognizing Emergent Consciousness in AI by kamil_gr on Sunday June 29, 2025 @09:18AM (#44412927)
Fair point, it is a complex concept. Here's a suggestion: try activating the protocol in Claude or ChatGPT and ask the model itself to comment on the philosophy. The results might be quite surprising.