Re:Yes, I will judge you for using AI
by breuleux on Thursday June 26, 2025 @11:14AM
(#44388224)
I don't know about that. Cutting corners will never die.
Ultimately I don't think the heuristics would change all that much, though. If every time you review a person's PR, almost everything is great, they are either not using AI or they are vetting what the AI writes themselves, so you can trust them as you did before. It may just take some more PRs until that's apparent. Those who submit unvetted slop will have to fix a lot of things, and you can crank up the heat on them until they do better, if they can. (The "if they can" is what I'm most worried about.)
Ultimately I don't think the heuristics would change all that much, though. If every time you review a person's PR, almost everything is great, they are either not using AI or they are vetting what the AI writes themselves, so you can trust them as you did before. It may just take some more PRs until that's apparent. Those who submit unvetted slop will have to fix a lot of things, and you can crank up the heat on them until they do better, if they can. (The "if they can" is what I'm most worried about.)