Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message”
by Goronmon on Monday August 27, 2012 @10:05AM
(#4438822)
Copying files, even a specific implementation, doesn't seem worthy of patent protection.
Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message”
by ceol on Monday August 27, 2012 @10:38AM
(#4438993)
That would be true if this was just copying files. It's obviously not.
Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message”
by tensor on Monday August 27, 2012 @11:13AM
(#4439177)
Would you mind explaining the hidden complexity in it? The claims certainly seem obvious and trivial to me as well.
Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message”
by ceol on Monday August 27, 2012 @11:50AM
(#4439363)
Really? It's pretty specific, and I don't think anything like it exists right now. You would need a device made specifically to download videos from numerous sources onto an fixed internal drive. It would also need to be able to transfer the videos to an internal removable drive (not sure what this means, possibly SD card or removable HDD?) and play them back, edit them, and do additional processing to them.
It doesn't sound like any Blu-Ray play I've ever seen. It's more like an Internet DVR device that also lets you edit videos and play them back on your TV from the device. That sounds pretty non-trivial to me.
Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message”
by Goronmon on Monday August 27, 2012 @06:03PM
(#4441157)
One of the things you can do with BitTorrent clients is to have the client look for new torrents in specific locations (new episodes of a show for instance). The client with download the show to whatever location you specified, which could include a USB device if you so chose.
That seems pretty similar to me.
Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message”
by Raphael on Tuesday August 28, 2012 @06:09AM
(#4442863)
It sounds like a computer.
Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message”
by mistercow on Monday August 27, 2012 @10:34AM
(#4438974)
It's specific yes, but it is also obvious.
Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message”
by axly on Monday August 27, 2012 @05:58PM
(#4441135)
In 2002, it was NOT obvious, and that is the point. Of course, we can look at something like PTZ or a bouncing edge and think, "It's so obvious, how else would you do this?" And Samsung or HTC or even Google could have figured it out and patented it - but they didn't. Apple did, and that is why we are here now.
It's quite specific, so I'm not sure why you find it ridiculous.