News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message” by mrcharles on Monday August 27, 2012 @08:54AM (#4438545)
As if pinch to zoom couldn't be suggested by a ten year old when presented with the problem of zooming on a multi-touch interface.

Software patents are a joke.

Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message” by pxlpshr on Monday August 27, 2012 @09:11AM (#4438608)
People hate on software patents like they were hating on the cellphone industry just 5 years ago.

One company doubled down on their innovation while disrupting their own major revenue channel. Meanwhile, the many stagnant phone manufactures continued copy/pasting crap because that's all they knew. BlackBerry executives went so far as to call Jobs' 2007 iPhone launch a "bluff" and an "impossible feat of engineering".

Maybe multi-touch is painfully obvious on the surface, but end-to-end execution and total consumer package made the iPhone what it is today -- and that wasn't obvious until you held it in your hand, and everything just clicked. So in that regard, I think it's fair for Apple to protect their entire pie by defending the slices/key ingredients.

PS. It took a few years before "pinch and zoom" was actually comparable to the fluidity of iOS. Some implementations on Android were a complete joke.

PPS. I don't disagree that the patent process could use some revisions, but to dismiss the process entirely is just silly -- including software.

Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message” by dsr_ on Monday August 27, 2012 @09:42AM (#4438728)
People were right to hate the cellphone industry 5 years ago. The best things available were Nokia candybar phones -- approaching the Ford Escort in terms of reliability -- and the Palm Treo, which was more or less the apex of combining a PDA with a phone without actually doing much integration. People are currently right to hate cellphone service providers.

As later history would reveal, BlackBerry executives were entirely correct to consider the iPhone an "impossible feat of engineering" -- from their point of view. RIM had huge market share, yet couldn't engineer its way out of a stapled paper bag.

Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message” by beedogs on Monday August 27, 2012 @09:49AM (#4438756)
There was also the HTC Wizard, introduced in October 2005.

It was pretty much the best thing out there for quite a while.

Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message” by watty on Monday August 27, 2012 @09:32AM (#4438684)
I agree it's the end-to-end execution that made the iPhone a success. But Samsung had a completely different end-to-end execution, right?

I agree with being able to sue for a complete copy of end-to-end, or even an attempt to. I just didn't see it in this case, especially with all the prior art. I don't understand the recipe analogy, to me it's like Bush's Beans suing another bean company for the inclusion of cocoa in the recipe. I'm baffled that you feel pinch to zoom should be patentable.

Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message” by taligent on Monday August 27, 2012 @09:53AM (#4438774)
No. That's the point of the case. Samsung DIDN'T have a completely different end to end execution. It was a blatant copy from the packaging, hardware design, software UI elements, connectors etc. And Samsung had documents demonstrating this.

Microsoft and Palm are examples of unique end to end execution.

Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message” by fluidcruft on Monday August 27, 2012 @09:37AM (#4438709)
I certainly hope that patents aren't intended to protect realizing that something has economic value. I personally hold "This is an obvious way to do this" and "I can make a lot of money if I do this" to be nearly orthogonal. I'm a little tired of people claiming Apple deserves government protection because they discovered a market.
Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message” by bitsoda on Monday August 27, 2012 @09:15AM (#4438629)
Apparently it wasn't so obvious in 2007 when all the handset makers scoffed at the iPhone.
Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message” by mrcharles on Monday August 27, 2012 @09:33AM (#4438687)
Pretty sure the big deal, if you break it down to component parts, was actually having a capacitive touch screen rather than resistive. Fingers instead of styluses opened a whole new world of phone interactions.

If they had patents on multitouch hardware itself, power to them. But software patents? Meh.

Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message” by JoelSutherland on Monday August 27, 2012 @09:43AM (#4438732)
Pinch and zoom in 2001 on a capacitive screen: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=waSXkJBKT1s&t=2m19s

This was presented in the case. Apple argued it didn't represent prior art because:

1. The screen was a projector and therefor this showed two devices. (Capacitive CRTs have excited since the 80s)

2. Samsung didn't present the code for this implementation in time, so it could not be proved that this was either object oriented or event-based.

So Apple's non-obvious extension of prior art was to 1. do this exact thing on a non-projector device, 2. use event-based code.

Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message” by mrcharles on Monday August 27, 2012 @09:50AM (#4438763)
So, basic software development on new hardware.

Gotcha.

Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message” by Kylekramer on Monday August 27, 2012 @09:33AM (#4438691)
Isn't scoffing at a new competitor just going through the motions required of you? No one is going to say "darn they beat us to it" to the press.
Re:Apple v. Samsung juror: we “wanted to send a message” by untog on Monday August 27, 2012 @09:27AM (#4438663)
I don't think anyone was scoffing because of pinch-to-zoom, though.