News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A federal judge sides with Anthropic in lawsuit over trai... by layer8 on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @01:35PM (#44368669)
But you can’t distribute it, which in the scenario mentioned in the parent’s final paragraph arguably happens.
Re:A federal judge sides with Anthropic in lawsuit over trai... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @03:11PM (#44369827)
You can't distribute the copyrighted works, but that isn't inherently the same thing as the model.

It's sort of like distributing a compendium of book reviews. Many of the reviews have quotes from the book. If there are thousands of reviews, you could potentially reconstruct the whole book, but that's not the point of the thing and so it makes sense for the infringing thing to be "using it to reconstruct the whole book" rather than "distributing the compendium".

And then Anthropic fended off the argument that their service was intended for doing the former because they were explicitly taking measures to prevent that.

Re:A federal judge sides with Anthropic in lawsuit over trai... by layer8 on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @04:15PM (#44370559)
The premise was that the model is able to reproduce the memorized text. In that sense it would be more like a compressed archive of the texts.
Re:A federal judge sides with Anthropic in lawsuit over trai... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @10:52PM (#44373261)
> Distributing a “machine” producing such output would constitute copyright infringement.

This is the thing you haven't established.

Any ordinary general purpose computer is a "machine" that can produce copyrighted text, if you tell it to. But isn't it pretty important whether you actually do that with it or not, since it's a general purpose tool that can also do a large variety of other things?