Is this still an active thing? My understanding is that both Xilinx and Altera/Intel have effectively discontinued their ASIC programs (Xilinx EasyPath, Altera HardCopy); they aren't available for modern part families.
For what it's worth, Xilinx EasyPath was never actually ASIC. The parts delivered were still FPGAs; they were just FPGAs with a reduced testing program focusing on functionality used by the customer's design.
Re:The FPGA Turns 40!
by CamperBob2 on Monday June 23, 2025 @09:05PM
(#44361881)
I'd be amazed if that were still possible, in fact. Real-world FPGA designs lean heavily on the vendor's proprietary IP, which won't port straight across to ASICs any more than the LUT-based FPGA fabric will.
Anyone who claims to turn a modern FPGA design into an ASIC "automatically" is selling snake oil.
Oh, these programs were always in-house. The offering was essentially "if you pay an up-front fee and give us your FPGA design, we'll sell you some chips that run that design for cheaper than the FPGAs". If there was ever any custom silicon involved - which there may have been for Altera, but probably not for Xilinx - the design files for it were never made available to the customer.
It is very possible and many vendors are still doing this. One of them was fairly recently acquired by Cisco.
Re:The FPGA Turns 40!
by CamperBob2 on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @11:53AM
(#44367549)
Automatic, without substantial NRE as well as active cooperation from brand X or brand A? BS.
Did you reply to the wrong message?
Re:The FPGA Turns 40!
by CamperBob2 on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @04:42PM
(#44370810)
No. Did you?
I did! :-)
> Real-world FPGA designs lean heavily on the vendor's proprietary IP
No, not always - I use no vendor IP whatsoever for extremely large designs.
For ASICs is basically required to use fab IP (for physical production/electrical/verification reasons,) but that's absolutely not the case for FPGAs.
Intel/Altera still has this:
https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/products/details/eas...
That's part of the FPGA business model - they have an automated way to take an FPGA design and turn it into a validated semi-custom ASIC, at low NRE, at silicon nodes(10nm?) you wouldn't have access to otherwise.
And all of that at a much lower risk. This is a strong rational but also emotional appeal. And people are highly influenced by that.