Re:uv: An extremely fast Python package and project manager,...
by Hasnep on Monday June 23, 2025 @07:39PM
(#44361346)
My experience is that ruff reimplemented 99% of the most popular features of black, isort, flake8, pylint, etc. and then added 10000% more features on top, that feels like a fair tradeoff to me.
I've converted multiple large Python codebases to ruff, and each time I just configure ruff as close to the previous tools as possible, then reformat the entire codebase with ruff and remove all the previous tools. The speed increase when linting alone is worth the minor formatting changes to me.
If you really insist on keeping isort's sorting then you could at least replace black and pylint, which would reduce the total number of tools by one.
Re:uv: An extremely fast Python package and project manager,...
by projectdelphai on Wednesday June 25, 2025 @02:54AM
(#44374317)
I think you're underestimating how "fast" uv really is. It's night and day different. The sentence that got me to switch and I echo still was: "uv is so fast, I sometimes don't even think it's actually doing anything". The first time I used it, I had to actually double check if uv actually was working and installing the packages that it was saying it was. There's a lot of reasons I've heard not to use it that kind of (not really) make sense (you don't want another package manager, you're happy with just base pip, etc). But if you're already using poetry, you really should just switch. uv is just poetry but without any waiting.
Even your most complicated projects should be able to switch within a day. The only reason I took any time was having to restructure my docker containers to work with uv instead of poetry. And that's mostly with my inexperience with docker, not because uv is complicated.
For moving to uv, I haven't heard a good story for what uv provides over Poetry rather than "is fast". The only unique thing that I am currently aware of is that uv can install Python itself, which gets rid of tools like Pyenv. I'm interested because of that, but "is fast" isn't enough of a reason.