News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by pvnick on Sunday August 26, 2012 @02:37PM (#4435806)
As someone who was entrenched in the music startup world for a while, I've concluded that the only way to save the music industry is for the major labels to die or become obsolete and for new, innovation-friendly content producers to emerge in their place. We need for music what Netflix is trying to do for movies/tv (see Lillyhammer, new Arrested Development season).

It's that broken.

Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by gabrielbutu on Sunday August 26, 2012 @04:59PM (#4436199)
It's important to give some credit to the role major labels play in the industry. It might not be the best theoretical system, but practical limitations mean this is something of a second best solution, it is feasible, and a world without a major label oligopoly might not be as rosy as imagined.

Majors might appear as obstacles in the latter stages of the distribution chain, sure, but earlier on they play a key role in ensuring the masses - that's not necessarily you or I but fans of popular music - get the very best. That's the best in talent, from song-writing to singing to producing to touring. For that, an institutional arrangement promising immense returns to those at the top is a decent incentive structure for distilling what gets to us. And even if you look further down the spectrum at the indie side of things, you might notice it mimics what the oligopolies do.

You hear about Bieber as a product of YouTube and yes, streaming was key to his success. But without Scooter Braun's contacts on the industry side of things, the conversations those facilitated behind the scenes, would Bieber have become the Bieber 'we' have come to know and love?

In the end, the music listener's quality of life has improved. For artists, it's tough out there but that's nothing new. The circumstances have changed but fame and money are still on the table for those willing to put skin in the game and lose 99 times out of 100. For those more concerned with the love of it all, they can rest assured their message is getting out to more people than ever (if it's worthwhile). It may not be the best conceivable scenario, but I don't see it doing music much harm longer term. If anything, expect more killer less filler.

And for fans of live music, it's never been better. The prices might be higher but so is the standard, the choice, the accessibility.

For Spotify, the road ahead is somewhat hazy and needs to be navigated as such. A few years of loss making activity make sense if it keeps growing, keeps hammering out deals, and creates the bulk of its value a number of years down the line.

Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by quesera on Sunday August 26, 2012 @05:29PM (#4436279)
Too subtle, I think. People will miss your pervasive irony.
Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by willwhitney on Sunday August 26, 2012 @02:51PM (#4435858)
I would be very excited for Spotify to start signing artists directly, without the major label middleman. It could let Spotify turn a profit on those artists while simultaneously paying out more to the people making the music.

As an insider, pvnick, do you think Spotify could ever pull that off without burning the bridges of its current label deals?

Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by rm999 on Sunday August 26, 2012 @03:10PM (#4435925)
Spotify already lets unsigned artists add their music through music aggregators like cdbaby: http://www.spotify.com/us/work-with-us/labels-and-artists/ar...

I suppose the music aggregators are a modern day take on record labels.

Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by k-mcgrady on Sunday August 26, 2012 @05:14PM (#4436237)
Not really, a label does much more than get an artists music in a store. Distributing the content is probably the easiest thing for artists to do on their own. Marketing, touring and merchandise are more complication and labels are still the best solution.
Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by rm999 on Sunday August 26, 2012 @05:23PM (#4436263)
Well, that's why I said "take" on it. These companies are actually doing quite a bit that a traditional label would do: they store the media (the digital version of manufacturing it), distribute it, and market it. I don't think a traditional label is always the best solution, especially for groups that will never be big enough to justify the huge upfront costs a label puts in.

These aggregators are really for the tail end of the spectrum: the 90% of bands who represent 1% of music listening time and don't have much hope of getting signed.

Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by pvnick on Sunday August 26, 2012 @03:03PM (#4435905)
They could, but only for a short while with small artists until the labels start seeing them as a competitor rather than something to be exploited. Once the labels start to feel threatened you can be 100% certain they will take their ball and go home. That and probably litigate against Spotify.
Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by ethank on Sunday August 26, 2012 @04:59PM (#4436200)
Assuming Spotify signs artists (or Apple for that matter), will they be willing to upfront costs against touring, recording, production? How would they structure recoupment? Apple could structure a better deal because they can cover mechanical royalties through download purchases. Spotify would be streaming only. The economics would be very, very tight.

It'd be hard for them to do a 360 deal to get revenue from the money making aspect of music (sponsorships and live), unless they also staffed up artist development (touring) and sponsorships/partnerships/biz dev.

Its not as easy as just "signing an artist"

If it was, we'd have already been disrupted by the indies.

Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by willwhitney on Sunday August 26, 2012 @05:12PM (#4436233)
I realize it's a complicated question, and that Spotify (or Apple, or any other company we love) couldn't just jump straight in and be an instant success. And while Apple certainly has the cash to cover upfront costs, staffing up, etc, Spotify probably doesn't, at least at large scale.

Are there cases where it would work, though? Bands that stumble upon internet fame are still the exception, but they exist, and it seems like they benefit much less from the visibility and other perks that traditional labels offer. Could a band like OK Go (back in their early days of YouTube success) be better off going directly through a distributor like Spotify, getting less up front, and getting a bigger revenue share? I know a couple of years ago they jumped from EMI (http://okgo.net/2010/03/10/onwards-and-upwards/). Maybe they could have done so earlier?

Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by ethank on Sunday August 26, 2012 @07:21PM (#4436636)
OK Go would still have to register with a publisher and a PRO if they wanted to see any residuals at all. If they just wanted to bypass music and be a "video" band they'd still have to manage the music bed in some fashion, even if through Tunecore or someone like that.

These "the labels must die" discussions get tedious because not many know what they do. I quit being at a label, but not because I think it should die, just because it was anyhow.

Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by snowwrestler on Sunday August 26, 2012 @06:22PM (#4436459)
Unfortunately piracy has the exact opposite effect--it strengthens major music labels by preferentially harming more responsible or smaller labels.

Major label A&R looks for young bands that it can sign to 360 deals and promote like crazy to teenagers. (For those not aware, a 360 deal means the label gets a cut of every revenue source: album sales, concert receipts, sync licenses, etc.)

Smaller labels do not have the capital to operate that way, or (in many cases) choose not to operate that way out of a greater sense of responsibility to the artist. As a result they are more dependent on their cut of album sales--which have declined tremendously under the pressure of piracy.

Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by eikenberry on Sunday August 26, 2012 @07:03PM (#4436592)
Depending more on album sales for revenue is stupid and will keep you very small. Albums are now merchandise, akin to shirts, posters and stickers. You don't get rich off them. If you cater to the fans you'll make some money as they like to collect things and support their band. But compared to other merchandise, albums are probably one of the least valuable.

Labels need to realize they are promotional agencies primarily and take a cut, like acting agencies. You promote them and help them get gigs. You get a cut of the profits in return.

Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by bri3d on Sunday August 26, 2012 @07:16PM (#4436627)
The problem is that there's already a promotional agency which takes a cut - the tour promoter! [0]

That industry is slowly converging to a state of brokenness near that of album-selling record labels, as Live Nation (themselves a Clear Channel spinoff) were allowed to merge with Ticketmaster in 2010 to form a unified ticketing, venue booking, and promotion cabal.

0: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tour_promoter

Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by eikenberry on Sunday August 26, 2012 @07:36PM (#4436674)
That's not a problem. That is just another player. There are tons of people taking a bite of the pie when it comes to actors. Yet they continue to make a living and so do their agents.
Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by ethank on Sunday August 26, 2012 @07:37PM (#4436677)
OK, I was waiting for a moment to dig up budget sheets.

As of 2010, these are the line items on a budget to release a major label record. The same (minus a few things) applies to indies.

PROMOTION:

Indie promo (paying someone to promote to radio)

Tip sheets (newsletter advertising)

Radio promo contests (those win-it-before-you-can-buy-it and fly-aways)

Radio marketing (ads)

^ the above breaks down by format. Formats are:

Alternative, Active/AOR/Rock, College, AAA, Specialty Format (ie, Urban).

--------------

MISC PROMOTION:

Radio shows (including artist travel, accommodations, etc)

Promotion CD's

Tip sheet design and prep

--------------

SALES:

Advertisement placements (ie, circulars, endcaps)

Retail Marketing

Outside retail marketing

Retail merch admats

--------------

ADVERTISING:

Print

TV

Radio

Online

Outdoor/sniping

Circulars

Prep and art production

--------------

STREET MARKETING

Merch

Promotions

Outside street team

Samplers

--------------

MISC MARKETING:

Advances, DJ advances

Remixes

General merch (ie, those funky things artists do to promote records)

--------------

PUBLICITY

Indie publicists (if the artist doesn't use the staff)

TV appearances (travel, etc)

Photo shoots

Press travel

Tour logistics (aka Artist Development)

Prints, bios, misc (copywriters, etc)

--------------

VIDEO:

Video production

Live footage, EPK cuts

VIDEO PROMOTION:

Video indies

Video promotions

Video duplication

--------------

TOURING:

Tour support

Tour marketing

Promo tours (including setup, crew, backline, travel)

Ticket buys (from the venues, these aren't free!)

--------------

ONLINE

Marketing

Website tech cost

Website design

Other tech (Facebook, widgets, games, Lee Martin)

--------------

PACKAGING

Art

Production

--------------

INTERNATIONAL MARKETING

Tour support

Promo tour

Publicity

Production

Misc

--------------

* Some of these aren't done. Some are much more expensive than others. Anyhow, a lot to be said about this but that's worthy of a blog post.

Also this has likely changed a bit recently.

Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by duaneb on Sunday August 26, 2012 @11:33PM (#4437309)
How effective is marketing in these days? I get all my music recommendations from friends.
Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by citricsquid on Sunday August 26, 2012 @11:46PM (#4437341)
Then you're a rarity.

Marketing is important, even more so than before in my opinion. Look at artists like One Direction, a group of talented boys but nothing special... then look at the hysteria that surrounds them, Justin Bieber is another good example.

The song "Call Me Maybe" is a perfect example. That song was released almost one year ago, but how many people had heard of it? Maybe a few thousand. Then Carly Rae Jepsen signs to the label ran by Justin Biebers manager earlier this year... now it has over 220,000,000 youtube views and almost everyone that pays attention to popular culture can recite the lyrics.

Marketing is everything. Sure it's not always traditional marketing -- billboards, tv spots -- but using existing artists too. Carly Rae Jepsen is famous because of Justin Biebers marketing power.

Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by jinushaun on Tuesday August 28, 2012 @11:54AM (#4444315)
If it wasn't for marketing, your friends would not have likely heard of them in order to recommend them to you. Marketing is more than just MTV and radio. That viral YouTube link you sent out was most likely started by someone in the music industry. That indie band? You know of them because someone marketed them.
Re:Pandora and Spotify Rake in the Money and Then Send It Of... by ethank on Monday August 27, 2012 @02:18AM (#4437669)
How pervasive is Lady Gaga and Justin Beiber and Foster the People, Gotye, Fun., etc, etc.

In summary: very.