News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell me about your favorite tree (a slow-web proposal) by Swizec on Monday June 23, 2025 @12:31PM (#44357452)
> a casual dismissal of the original claim without anything of substance to back that up

I am not dismissing it. I miss the old internet too.

But what I’ve found is that I miss the free time to explore a lot more. When I find that, there is suddenly plenty of good people on the internet sharing interesting things. But usually in my busy life I scurry past without even noticing.

For example: there are entire corners of instagram devoted to people with a few hundred followers sharing daily chicken drama from their farms. Like a soap opera with daily updates … about chickens. Doesn’t get more “describe your favorite tree” than that

Re:Tell me about your favorite tree (a slow-web proposal) by 9rx on Monday June 23, 2025 @12:42PM (#44357569)
> there are entire corners of instagram devoted to people with a few hundred followers sharing daily chicken drama from their farms.

Difference is that when FishCam went live, it was "Wait. What? You can do that?" Now: "Of course you can share video on the internet."

We still get the occasional "Wait. What? You can do that?" moments — when we witnessed LLMs, for example — but we aren't inundated with them on a near-daily basis like we were in the age of the old internet, when everything about it was new and people were continually testing its limits.

In other words, it is mature now. There is no bringing back the magic.

Re:Tell me about your favorite tree (a slow-web proposal) by Swizec on Monday June 23, 2025 @12:59PM (#44357734)
> We still get the occasional "Wait. What? You can do that?"

1. From the perspective of a kid, everything is like that.

At 17 I was amazed by all sorts of things that my older peers yawned at and said "Yeah we could do that 10 years ago on desktop/mainframe/whatever". I now work with a lot of youngins. Their minds are blown by all sorts of things I find boring because we (the industry) started working on them 10+ years ago.

2. There's a lot of "wow you can do that!?" out there but it's locked in niches.

Right now I'm working on bringing bioinformatics tools to the web. It is blowing people's minds. To me the tech feels boring and obvious, to the biotech researchers it's like their whole world is revolutionizing (and they tell us as much).

Re:Tell me about your favorite tree (a slow-web proposal) by 9rx on Monday June 23, 2025 @01:16PM (#44357891)
> 1. From the perspective of a kid, everything is like that.

To some degree, but, for example, the car wasn't as mind blowing to my generation as my parents' and grandparents'. And the kids today don't seem to recognize it as anything special at all. I expect you can say that about any technology. The telephone (not to be confused with a pocket computer) meant nothing to me, but was one of the greatest inventions ever known to people from an earlier time. There seems to be a natural decline as something reaches greater and greater maturity. Who here is thrilled by, say, the threshing machine? Who here even knows what a threshing machine is...?

> 2. There's a lot of "wow you can do that!?" out there but it's locked in niches.

Like I said, we're not inundated with it anymore. There are still special moments here and there, to be sure, but they don't come around often, so it is not the same continual high we once lived when the internet was new. Again, I think you can say that about anything becoming more and more mature. Going back to the car, in the early days they quickly improved with new features and better technology. Cars too lived the same "Wait. What? You can do that?" period. Now? A slightly larger infotainment screen is the biggest selling feature. Boring.

Admittedly, the driverless car hype got us really excited for a while, but the ball was kind of dropped on that one. Quite possibly the greatest marketing blunder of all time, and as a result I'm not sure the emotions have been able to recover as we start to see the technology actually be realized.

Re:Tell me about your favorite tree (a slow-web proposal) by Swizec on Monday June 23, 2025 @01:47PM (#44358252)
I think you would enjoy reading up on the Gartner hype cycle. It’s basically what you’re describing

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gartner_hype_cycle

Web and possibly mobile are deep into plateau of productivity