Re:Clinical trials: Unfavorable results often go unpublished
by tocomment on Wednesday January 21, 2009 @01:32PM
(#443568)
I wonder if the double blind model can be applied right into the publishing stage? Or perhaps journals could have some requirement, 50/50 positive/negative results.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Clinical trials: Unfavorable results often go unpublished
by cninja on Wednesday January 21, 2009 @02:10PM
(#443629)
I think that the problem is we consider a result as either "positive" or "negative". All correctly preformed experiments add a positive ammount of knowledge. Humans tend to classify unexpected results as negative, but that is not necessary.
Re:Clinical trials: Unfavorable results often go unpublished
by etal on Thursday January 22, 2009 @12:02AM
(#444386)
That's not what negative means here. For these studies the conclusion is a statistical test -- accept or reject the null hypothesis. If a drug doesn't give results significantly different from a placebo, that's "negative". More to the point, when a researcher collects a pile of data, does some analysis, and can't see a damn thing either way, then either the experiment was flawed to begin with, or that absence of meaning is a real, useful result. Maybe the sample size just wasn't large enough to show a small but significant trend. It takes a fair amount of confidence in one's skills to rule out the first possibility and announce loudly that there's nothing to be seen further down the path you took.
Re:Clinical trials: Unfavorable results often go unpublished
by omouse on Wednesday January 21, 2009 @02:14PM
(#443635)
The problem then is that humans don't know how to use definitions. In a specific study, a result can be negative, but in the general view, it would be positive because it contributes to the body of science.