News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla launches robotaxi rides in Austin with promises and... by jdminhbg on Monday June 23, 2025 @01:29AM (#44352692)
> I'm curious what gives you such blind faith that Tesla's vision-only tech will work out.

Obviously, only vision and hearing are required for driving. The question isn't "can it work," the question is "which approach will be economically viable on what time scale, and is there a winner-takes-all dynamic that excludes the approach that comes second."

Re:Tesla launches robotaxi rides in Austin with promises and... by brettp on Monday June 23, 2025 @01:41AM (#44352750)
I've never understood the argument "humans only use vision and hearing so self driving cars should too". We don't constrain what we do with machines to what humans do.

Humans don't have wheels either. Is Tesla planning to replace wheels in their cars with legs, Flintstones style?

Re:Tesla launches robotaxi rides in Austin with promises and... by smallmancontrov on Monday June 23, 2025 @09:55AM (#44355851)
That's not the argument and never was. Humans aren't proof that you can't do better than vision, we are proof that the problem can be solved with vision.

This isn't a question of max-sensors vs min-sensors, though. It's a question of max-sensors vs max-data under economics constraints that forbade "why not both?". Tesla chose max-data, and they now have a 40x data advantage thanks to their choice, and probably more once you consider the improved diversity of data collected from private cars in every corner of the country and world.

If you were training a self-driving car, would you rather have 40x the data or would you rather have point clouds that are only a smidgen better than what you can get from modern monocular depth reconstruction on the vision data?

Re:Tesla launches robotaxi rides in Austin with promises and... by tzs on Monday June 23, 2025 @04:15PM (#44359606)
> Humans aren't proof that you can't do better than vision, we are proof that the problem can be solved with vision.

It's proof that the problem can be solved with vision when your driver is a human. That doesn't necessarily prove it for non-human drivers implemented on currently known AI architectures.

Humans can learn from a lot less data then current non-human AIs require. We also learn in the field, often recognizing when we've made a mistake and consciously updating ourselves to handle similar situations better in the future. It is possible that this is necessary to make vision only driving work well.

Re:Tesla launches robotaxi rides in Austin with promises and... by smallmancontrov on Monday June 23, 2025 @06:54PM (#44361037)
You dodged the question about whether you would choose 40x data or redundant depth maps.

I think you dodged the question because you know that 40x data is the clear winner.

Re:Tesla launches robotaxi rides in Austin with promises and... by tzs on Monday June 23, 2025 @09:49PM (#44362134)
I didn't dodge the question. I didn't even consider it enough to form an opinion.

I responded to the part of your comment that interested me, which concerned what we can infer from the ability of humans to do vision based driving.

Re:Tesla launches robotaxi rides in Austin with promises and... by smallmancontrov on Saturday July 05, 2025 @10:41AM (#44473107)
You dodged it again lol.
Re:Tesla launches robotaxi rides in Austin with promises and... by jdminhbg on Monday June 23, 2025 @12:34PM (#44357481)
I didn’t say nobody should try to solve the problem using lidar, I just said humans are an existence proof that it can be done. Lidar gives you more data, but maybe that data will turn out to be overkill. We’ll find out.