Re:Why it's so hard to find a photo of Neil Armstrong on the...
by regularfry on Sunday August 26, 2012 @06:33AM
(#4434819)
To play a slightly comical devil's advocate, what if Neil Armstrong had intentionally angled the camera down to avoid photographing their flying saucer escort? From the original it's not obvious that the area above Buzz Aldrin's helmet is black.
Yes, I know, it is really, but you don't know that from the photo, and that's an important distinction when you don't know the full context your reporting of the photo will be presented in at a future date. I think the argument is that crops and rotations are generally ok (although the argument about the upside-down footprint is interesting), but a transformation which claims to add information not originally in the photo cannot be ok.
Re:Why it's so hard to find a photo of Neil Armstrong on the...
by m_for_monkey on Sunday August 26, 2012 @08:15AM
(#4434938)
Even a simple crop can make a large effect: http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread545972/pg1
If crops, borders, rotations, etc. constitute "doctoring" then virtually every publicity photo NASA releases has been doctored. And if those minor transformations aren't allowed then surely none of the composite photos from the Mars probes are acceptable either, right? Compositing is way more invasive than cropping and rotating.
At any rate, NASA has published the raw version of all their photos and therefore, everything is verifiable.