News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft suspended the email account of an ICC prosecuto... by spwa4 on Saturday June 21, 2025 @03:41PM (#44340191)
> The ICC only has jurisdiction over the territories and nationals of the State Parties to the Rome Statute

If this is the case can you explain ICC action against US and Israel, neither of which are parties to the Rome statute? This is one aspect of their selective justice. And some of the crimes they accuse Russia of (e.g. the ones relating to treatment of POWs) happened in Russia too, you could even say the same of their "great success" in Yugoslavia. The ICC respects boundaries selectively.

Also from the other side: the ICC most certainly COULD sue South Africa for working with Putin and Bashar Al-Assad to help them escape justice. They chose not to. Frankly, MANY signatories to the Rome statute have zero intention to ever hold up their end.

Also, of course, this rule is also selective justice if it is applied.

In a lot of state vs "resistance movement" the ICC has systematically failed to do anything about sometimes truly abhorrent crimes by movements. No shortage of examples there.

And your claim "they follow their own rules" ... you also neglected to discuss why the ICC changed it's own statutes TWICE to sue Israel ... once during the trial I might add. Same with US. Not that "we couldn't convict the Jew, obviously the law is wrong, let's change the law" isn't a longstanding legal tradition. Not very just though ...

As I said, the ICC is a beautiful theoretical idea. Unfortunately the ICC is not even remotely close to that idea and will never be. Their rules form selective justice even if they were applied and what they practically do is much worse than that.

Re:Microsoft suspended the email account of an ICC prosecuto... by vidarh on Sunday June 22, 2025 @04:14AM (#44344986)
> Your entire argument boils down do "this is legal for the ICC, and that that definition of legal differs greatly from your sense of justice doesn't matter"

No. No part of my comment was about that at all.

> is the case can you explain ICC action against US and Israel, neither of which are parties to the Rome statute

The ICC does not take actions against states. As for the actions against Israeli officials, those are taken on the basis of actions relating to Palestine, over which ICChas jurisdiction be cause Palestine is party to the court. I explained this.

> Also from the other side: the ICC most certainly COULD sue South Africa for working with Putin and Bashar Al-Assad to help them escape justice.

No, it could not. The ICC does not have jurisdiction over states. For the ICC to act would require evidence of specific individuals violating the Rome Statute.

> They chose not to. Frankly, MANY signatories to the Rome statute have zero intention to ever hold up their end.

Here we agree, for once. This is indeed a problem.

> And your claim "they follow their own rules" ... you also neglected to discuss why the ICC changed it's own statutes TWICE to sue Israel ...

They did not, and the ICC does not sue anybody, and the ICC can not pursue states. Every part of this sentence is wrong and or misunderstands how the ICC works.