Once they had their criteria for evaluating infringement, they could hammer through the devices pretty quickly. I suspect that most of the deliberation was on if the patents were valid or not. If so, how then to evaluate if a device infringed?
I'm more curious to know how they determined damages... it seems like there should be a worksheet or something on that.
People tend to defer to perceived experts, which is why I find it odd Samsung's attorneys didn't catch this guy.
More likely, they knew about him and made a bet he would side with them. They were wrong.
Of course the law is full of funny cases (like the time the Supreme Court filed a per curiam, and then along with it a unanimous partial concurrence). Figuring out what was meant there is... well, something lawyers can argue about forever.
The verdict form in this complex case necessarily spans 20 pages and requires unanimous answers to more than 500 discrete questions across 5 different legal disciplines. (Dtk. No. 1890.) The likelihood of an inconsistent verdict is a possibility despite the jury’s best efforts.
"DESPITE THE JURY'S BEST EFFORTS"
Groklaw even linked to the source of the above quote: http://www.groklaw.net/pdf3/ApplevSamsung-1927.pdf
Seems like a classic case of confirmation bias, by both Groklaw as well as a bunch of people here.