News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open source can't coordinate by taeric on Thursday June 19, 2025 @10:24PM (#44324202)
I'm not entirely clear why/how this is an open source issue?

My assertion: Inertia of user base is by far the largest predictor of what will stick in a market. If you can create a critical mass of users, then you will get a more uniform set of solutions.

For fun, look into bicycles and how standardized (or, increasingly not) they are. Is there a solid technical reason for multiple ways to make shoes that connect to pedals? Why are there several ways to shift from your handlebars? With the popularity of disk brakes, why don't we have a standard size for pads?

I think there are a lot of things that we tell ourselves won from some sort of technical reasoning. The more you learn of things, the less this seems true, though.

Not, btw, that there aren't some things that die due to technical progress.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by FridgeSeal on Friday June 20, 2025 @12:14AM (#44324690)
> For fun, look into bicycles and how standardized (or, increasingly not) they are.

Because triangles are a fantastic, high-strength shape, that suits the loads a bicycle is subject to. For the vast majority of cases, it’s a very solid choice. We deviate when specific UX requirements are required (city bikes having a battery and a low stepover to suit a variety of clothing, and the motor makes up for additional weight required.

> Is there a solid technical reason for multiple ways to make shoes that connect to pedals?

All of them attempt to address the same requirement, and make different tradeoffs depending on use-case and environment.

> Why are there several ways to shift from your handlebars?

Price points, performance reqs, handlebar setup, environmental (is it expected to be subject to mud rocks and trees constantly?) and weight.

> With the popularity of disk brakes, why don't we have a standard size for pads?

Same as for shifters: the braking compound and design for a race road bike will be really different to what a DH race bike requires.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by prmoustache on Friday June 20, 2025 @06:01AM (#44326206)
> All of them attempt to address the same requirement, and make different tradeoffs depending on use-case and environment.

All road shoes/pedals interface have the same requirements. All XC ones have the same ones, All Dh ones, same.

> Same as for shifters: the braking compound and design for a race road bike will be really different to what a DH race bike requires.

Regardless if we are talking shifters, breaks or pedals interface among a specific line (road, gravel, xc, DH) the requirements stay the same and more importantly those formats/shapes/interface almost never vary accross price point:

All mtb shifters from a given manufacturer and amount of gears available are usually interchangeable. A deore shifter can operate an XTR derailleur. Same SPD cleats accross all MTB pedals from Shimano. Same brake pad shape is used accross all lines for a given number of pistons. More importantly pads and calipers are usually interchangeable between road and mtb for a given manufacturer. Conpound, requirements and price point as little to do with it as manufacturers release pads with different compound but same shape.

What makes all these formats not standards is because every manufacturer wants to have its own for 2 reasons: 1) think it knows better 2) aim to capture a market and become a monopoly (through cleats format)

Only rarely they discuss between each others or release a standard and don't ask for royalties. Same as proprietary software vendors.

The open source fragmentation only really comes from reason 1.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by ClumsyPilot on Friday June 20, 2025 @09:35AM (#44327620)
> > With the popularity of disk brakes, why don't we have a standard size for pads? Same as for shifters: the braking compound and design for a race road bike will be really different to what a DH race bike requires

I really don’t understand how this mentality Uk survives.

for the past 100 years companies have been working to get unfair advantage over each other by creating user lock-in, patent trolling each-other, DRM in games, changing their design to break compatibility with generic products etc.

surely you must realise that many motivations for product difference have no bearing on user benefit, or we would never have region-locking on DVDs or proprietary media formats.

Bicycle market is not a healthy competitive market. Shimano makes almost all gears for all bikes in Europe. For the price of an electric cargo bike that goes 15 mph and has 0.6 kWh battery I can buy an electric motorbike that goes 70 mph and has 6 kWh battery.

They are both about £4,000

Re:Open source can't coordinate by skydhash on Thursday June 19, 2025 @11:39PM (#44324515)
> I'm not entirely clear why/how this is an open source issue?

I think it's not even an issue. Most open source projects are implementations (maybe flawed), and few are new propositions. If something was not fully defined in the standard/protocol/interface, the implementation may come up with its own extensions that are incompatible with others. But that's how you choose implementations, you're supposed to commit to one and not use a mismatch.

So if you're using GNOME, try not to depend on something that depends on having the whole KDE installed. If you're using OpenRC, anything systemd is prohibited. All projects are consistent within themselves, the only thing you need to do is to avoid conflicts by having two things doing the same job and to ollow the installed system guidelines.

I don't mind fragmentation. What I mind is dependency due to laziness and not a real need (like using a couple of glibc specific library for no real reason just because you're working on Debian) or taking the time to support windows and macos, but tying yourself to glibc on Linux because reasons.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by graemep on Friday June 20, 2025 @12:22PM (#44329288)
> So if you're using GNOME, try not to depend on something that depends on having the whole KDE installed.

I disagree with this bit. When i used a Gtk desktop I still used KDE applications so I had lots of KDE libraries installed. I use KDE now and I still have lots of Gtk applications installed.

Its slightly wasteful of storage and memory but is still a lot less resource hungry than Windows.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by LtWorf on Sunday June 22, 2025 @11:53AM (#44347907)
In my experience most people who want to avoid the glibc do so because they disagree with the values of free software.

After this premise, can you explain to me why I should waste my time to help them? Let's not forget that we are talking about open source software and they could fix it themselves if they so desire.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by pixl97 on Friday June 20, 2025 @12:08AM (#44324656)
>why don't we have a standard size for pads?

Because each manufacturer can't put a premium on their pads that way.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by dkkergoog on Thursday June 19, 2025 @10:51PM (#44324317)
All those things have s price point
Re:Open source can't coordinate by bloppe on Friday June 20, 2025 @12:21AM (#44324726)
It's really not an open source issue. It's a more general issue than that. The author provides as counterexamples MacOS and Windows, but that's a silly comparison. Apple nor Microsoft never coordinated with anybody else on their APIs. Closed source developers are never as good at coordinating with others as OSS developers are. Sure, they can invest more in their own products, but that's a different issue.

Also, I'm not sure what kind of standard this author is pining for. We have Wayland and freedesktop.org. Pretty much any Linux app can already run on pretty much any DE

Re:Open source can't coordinate by mbreese on Friday June 20, 2025 @12:43AM (#44324802)
I don’t think of it as a coordination issue. OSS can coordinate well. What it can’t do is make decisions. Most times there are at least two possible implementations for a given task (with different legitimate trade-offs). The OSS approach isn’t to pick the implementation that works for the most people, but rather support both implementations. Many times the only decision is to not to decide.

The best projects have someone who will make unilateral decisions. They might be right or wrong, but it’s done and decided. Companies with an organizational hierarchy do that much better than a decentralized group of OSS developers.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by pjc50 on Friday June 20, 2025 @04:55AM (#44325797)
The underappreciated benefit of OSS is that you have an escape hatch from coordination if you disagree enough. You can in theory just fork it and run your own version, even if nobody else agrees. But you have to bear the associated development cost yourself.

Choice looks like fragmentation. But the existence of alternatives is very important.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by transcriptase on Friday June 20, 2025 @08:52AM (#44327233)
Until someone wants to switch from Windows/MacOS to Linux and is presented with two dozen popular distros, half a dozen desktop choices for each with no explanation of what the acronyms mean or why someone should care, immediately gets prompted about things like bootloaders and various partition schemes, until they finally get to a desktop and their mouse is stuck at 0.01% pointer speed regardless of what the mouse options are set to because the maintainer of sdctlxinputmd got mad at the maintainer of some dependency and decided the user can install and configure what lets sdctlxinputmd work with the OS settings panel. Oh except installing those requires configuring new sources and overriding disallowing proprietary drivers because some other maintainer is a purist who added friction because Nvidia doesn’t provide their firmware source code under the PLGPPGL 4.1 Licence.
Re:Open source can't coordinate by noisy_boy on Friday June 20, 2025 @10:06AM (#44327868)
Given fairly well made mainstream distros like Ubuntu basically just work nowadays, I think it is a bit rich to shit on Linux with snarky remarks. Nobody is denying that there is certain lack of cohesiveness, niggling issues that annoy us but most of the time they are not dealbreakers. There used to be a thousand papercuts but not anymore - sure its not zero. Afterall it is made by volunteers for free because they have an itch to scratch or they like programming or want to give back something to the world etc.

You didn't pay a dime for it, except with your time on things that annoy you, which is indeed not free. But if your time is that precious and you are that exacting, maybe Linux isn't a good fit for you. Maybe you should try paying for the perfectly crafted commercial alternatives. Except in the real world, those alternatives are far from perfect and have tons of issues like spyware, bloat, ads being shoved down the users throat and so on - on top of the papercuts/annoyances that sometimes take years to fix.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by transcriptase on Friday June 20, 2025 @02:01PM (#44330232)
I’ve been using Linux daily since people were saying the same about Mandrake to people complaining about Gentoo requiring part-time job levels of effort to make it capable of basic functionality. Don’t mistake the recognition of very real hurdles to widespread adoption (brought on by fragmentation) with some sort of lack of experience on my part. I love Linux, except for when the simplest little things become nightmarish time-sucks and you find out it has nothing to do with technical complexity but because of some ideological argument a couple of guys had on a mailing list in 1999.
Re:Open source can't coordinate by noisy_boy on Friday June 20, 2025 @09:02PM (#44333606)
> Don’t mistake the recognition of very real hurdles to widespread adoption (brought on by fragmentation) with some sort of lack of experience on my part.

Everybody recognizes the hurdles. But they are there because of the nature of the ecosystem. Unpaid skilled maintainers are hard to get and it takes specific kind of people to maintain a driver or a subsystem, for sometimes decades. Those personalities sometimes come with strong opinions and prejudices and such. Does that delay fixing of end user issues? Yes. If there was an easy solution, it would be implemented by now.

Funny you bring up Mandrake because I paid a good chunk of my salary to buy a box that came with the CD and a small printed book. I have been using Linux through thick and thin everyday since then.

> I love Linux

Me too! Let's not be too harsh on our loved one :)

Re:Open source can't coordinate by nyrikki on Friday June 20, 2025 @10:26AM (#44328029)
Still not an open source specific example.

1) Due to the stability of the Linux kernel ABI, switching distros is far easier than between Interactive, SCO, SunOS, IIRC, Ultrix etc...

There have only really been two major bootloaders in x86 Linux, Lilo and Grub, and the disk partitioning was driven by DOS/Windows and is still simpler than the dozens of differences between the commercial UNIXs or even adding on ons like VXVM.

I have switched Linux distros at a data center level several times in my career due to various reasons and it has only ever been constrained by downtime budgets, and typically is faster and easier than a major window upgrade, even before modern tools existed.

Different groups are always going to make different decisions, and those decisions will change over time within even single groups.

Nvidia drivers are a complete mess, even without licence concerns.

IMHO, with modern tools, you should let the application drive distro choices if needed, reserving your preferred distro for more generic needs that don't suffer from app vendor coupling.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by bloppe on Friday June 20, 2025 @09:29AM (#44327569)
This is funny but it's telling that people often resort to exaggerations to paint Linux as hard to use. Any major distro is a lot easier to set up than it was 15 years ago.

Sure, most people's eyes gloss over the moment I try to explain the distinction between Linux and GNU, but if you're really that uncurious about how the system works then what's the point of switching to Linux anyway. Windows / Mac already get you most of the way there, especial now that WSL is a thing.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by graemep on Friday June 20, 2025 @12:34PM (#44329430)
> what's the point of switching to Linux anyway. Windows / Mac already get you most of the way there

What is the point of using Windows or Mac when Linux will get you most of the way there?

Linux has a lot of advantages for users who are not interested in the technology. Longer hardware upgrade cycle, ease of maintenance and upgrades, more resource efficient, more secure (partly because it is less targetted as a desktop - but what matters is if you use Linux you are less likely to have issues), better privacy....

Re:Open source can't coordinate by const_cast on Friday June 20, 2025 @04:15PM (#44331644)
I agree, which is why we have a trope of grandma running Elementary OS. Windows is not actually easy to use or intuitive at all - it's just popular. Which, if you squint hard enough, looks a lot of intuitiveness. But it's not actually.
Re:Open source can't coordinate by bloppe on Friday June 20, 2025 @01:46PM (#44330100)
I've been daily-driving Linux for decades. I know how valuable it is. But I'm also "that guy" who likes examining every little piece of my system. I thought we were talking about the normies who just "hear good things" about Linux (especially soft-core developers) but aren't really interested in everything going on under the hood, and are willing to shell out a grand or two every couple years for new hardware and tech support.
Re:Open source can't coordinate by graemep on Friday June 20, 2025 @04:31PM (#44331796)
I am talking about normies. not even developers. I mean my family, for example. My late dad used Linux for many years, my daughters do, my ex-wife used to (possibly still does). None are developers, although my daughters are somewhat technically inclined and can program (the older one is an engineer).

The point I am trying to make is that there are advantages for people who are NOT interested in every detail of the system.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by mbreese on Friday June 20, 2025 @06:47PM (#44332821)
> … paint Linux as hard to use. Any major distro is a lot easier to set up than it was 15 years ago.

See, I don’t necessarily think Linux is hard to use. Most desktop environments are so similar in style to Windows and Mac that they are pretty intuitive.

To me, setup is often the hardest part. It can be easy with some hardware. But if you aren’t lucky, getting a system running can be tricky.

This is one area where having someone who can make decisions is really helpful. Apple can make sure their software works with their exact hardware specs. Microsoft has various compatibility guidelines and enough market share to make sure they are always supported. Linux is fragmented and hardware support lags because of this.

Then you have smaller hardware vendors who support one obscure distro, but if that’s not what you want to run good luck. I spent last week trying to get Debian running on a Pine 64 laptop and still don’t have working sound.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by ykclakuf on Friday June 20, 2025 @09:12AM (#44327409)
That wasn't really a problem even a bit over a decade earlier when I started looking into switching things up. You look what is popular, you install ubuntu, it goes to usb stick which you insert in computer -> click next until you're on desktop. Nothing special.

I think the really annoying parts were more related to nothing being quite perfect; things tearing, having iffy support for mixed resolution and refresh rates, sometimes browser not using hw acceleration and fans spinning up. Everything you could live with, but dealing papercuts.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by WD-42 on Friday June 20, 2025 @10:44AM (#44328193)
Same old copium from the people that can’t bring themselves to give up their proprietary os
Re:Open source can't coordinate by lelanthran on Friday June 20, 2025 @03:35PM (#44331192)
"Show us on the doll where open source software touched you"
Re:Open source can't coordinate by transcriptase on Saturday June 21, 2025 @11:08AM (#44338163)
$ show show: symbol lookup error: /usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/libimageproc.so.2: undefined symbol: jpeg_mem_src@LIBJPEG_8.0, version LIBJPEG_8.0 not defined in file libjpeg.so.8 with link time reference
Re:Open source can't coordinate by Asooka on Friday June 20, 2025 @04:57PM (#44332019)
> You can in theory just fork it and run your own version

That is not feasible for a large portion of users. Even seasoned developers would struggle to maintain a personal fork of anything but the simplest open-source software. Proprietary software also has an escape hatch, it's called "Voting with your wallet", i.e. giving your money to someone else who solves your problem better. The set of people who have money is much larger than the set of computer programmers.

Giving money to software you want to support has proven to be the most reliable way to direct software development. Granted, sometimes you're a Softimage user and Autodesk acquires the company making your software and then kills it to remove competition for their other 3D programs. Those cases are much rarer than the case where you want a consistently supported GUI for your OS and your only option is to write it yourself.

When you think about it, development of proprietary software is a lot more democratised than open-source software, because average users can direct where development goes by voting with their wallets, or even without their wallets in the case of piracy, which still drives development via second-order network effects. BitTorrent has done more for practical software freedom than GNU ever did.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by FinnKuhn on Friday June 20, 2025 @08:06AM (#44326914)
In recent years it appears that at least for Microsoft different teams working on Windows also aren't really coordinating with each other resulting in a scattered OS with duplicated implementations of similar features and a dozen different UI styles.
Re:Open source can't coordinate by tbrownaw on Friday June 20, 2025 @08:48AM (#44327207)
> The author provides as counterexamples MacOS and Windows, but that's a silly comparison. Apple nor Microsoft never coordinated with anybody else on their APIs.

No, but each of those two systems is ruled by one dictator and has one blessed way to do things. For example in the Windows / .NET world, it's WinForms, er I mean WPF, er I mean...

> Also, I'm not sure what kind of standard this author is pining for.

It sounds like a wish for the clarity of a cathedral rather than the chaos of a bazaar.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by bloppe on Friday June 20, 2025 @09:17AM (#44327474)
It's a silly comparison because the author implies that OSS is a monolith that's failing to coordinate amongst its parts, whereas proprietary software firms are individuals that excel at self-coordination but are never expected to coordinate amongst each other.

Individual OSS projects are often good at self-coordination. You don't need standards if you just reinvent the wheel yourself AKA how proprietary software often works.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by jowea on Friday June 20, 2025 @03:22PM (#44331067)
Maybe it's a bunch of volunteers vs large hierarchical for profit organizations? Even through there are some of the latter working on FOSS.
Re:Open source can't coordinate by em3rgent0rdr on Friday June 20, 2025 @12:25AM (#44324741)
> not entirely clear why/how this is an open source issue?

Was going to say this too, cause competing proprietary software companies generally don't coordinate. Macs don't easily run Windows programs and vice versa. Unless an alliance or some agreement to adhere to some standards body is made, the collaboration issue is part of both worlds.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by Bouncingsoul1 on Friday June 20, 2025 @02:27AM (#44325218)
I'm not sure which point you are trying to make with the bikes. For road racing the UCI quite famously sets quite strict standards. For "normal" use, if you live within the US or EU will also have some standards (mostly conserning road saftey). Of course you may cherry pick some exceptions, but IMO this doesn't drive the point.
Re:Open source can't coordinate by prmoustache on Friday June 20, 2025 @06:03AM (#44326211)
UCI only has power on formats [1] used in race. It definitely influences the market but it has no say on which width of handlebar can I use on my own bike as long as I don't pin a number in a UCI sanctionnd race.

[1] I prefer using that word because most aren't really standardised.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday June 20, 2025 @10:57AM (#44328334)
And also, not sure how the ratios are today, but 8 years ago, an order of magnitude more people raced bicycles in triathlons than in UCI sanctioned races, where the UCI has no control.
Re:Open source can't coordinate by skywhopper on Friday June 20, 2025 @08:43AM (#44327169)
It’s not at all. As a counter-example, in the 00s, open source rapidly coalesced to using git, which has been so incredibly successful that it has now been adopted for many private corporate proprietary software repositories as well.

I don’t think you can take a general lesson from any particular example here. Coordination of complex systems among thousands of competing and cooperative components is very hard and unpredictable, and why things happen depends on random events and personalities in ways that are not generalizable.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by ClumsyPilot on Friday June 20, 2025 @09:29AM (#44327568)
> Inertia of user base is by far the largest predictor of what will stick in a market

Why are you calling open source of market?

These appear to be feuds and battle of ideas fought between contributors, with minimal input from end users. There is no price signal at all

Re. Bicycles, it’s not a healthy market. Shimano dominates with 70% share in gears and brakes. Top 3 manufacturers have what, 95%+? Also look at how cargo bikes cost 3x what a normal bike does, but have same components.

With that structure, users have zero input on size of breakpads.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by thewebguyd on Friday June 20, 2025 @11:32AM (#44328691)
There's still an agreement on what's beneficial, even if the how isn't standardized. TO use your bicycle analogy, it's widely accepted that clipping into pedals is beneficial, we've found it improves power transfer and efficiency - the idea of clipping in is standardized, but the implementation (cleat design) is still open for interpretation.

We see this in open source too - we can coordinate and all agree on a core idea or problem that needs solving, but still end up with different, competing implementations. It's not a bad thing, choice is good and often leads to innovation as different approaches compete and evolve.

I do think you are right on your first point - that inertia of user base is the predictor of what will stick. Even Linux, stuck around due to licensing and availability (and then user inertia from that) rather than any technical superiority.

Re:Open source can't coordinate by AcaciaSkier on Friday June 20, 2025 @11:39AM (#44328774)
> Is there a solid technical reason for multiple ways to make shoes that connect to pedals?

Yes!

- Toe clips give you more power than just flat pedals. You can use regular shoes with them.

- Straps (similar to toe clips) can and be used with regular shoes / trainers and allow you to control the pedal stroke up and down. Fixed gear riders use them a lot.

- MTB style cleats are easier to unclip and re-clip than Road style cleats as you are more likely to need to clip / unclip quickly.

- Road style cleats provide better power transfer, the shoes are far stiffer as well.

> Why are there several ways to shift from your handlebars?

Two reasons. The first is that the technology has improved over time. I have ridden old racing bikes where the shifter was not on the handlebar and on the downtube. You had to feel the position of the next gear while steering with the other hand. It is difficult for people that haven't ridden a road bike before to get used to.

Secondly the different types of bikes have the rider in different positions and thus their hands will be in a different position. Thus the different shifter types.

The moral of the story is that different requirements, require different solutions.

BTW almost everything else around the pedal and the shifter is standardised. The hub are normally one of a few sizes, wheel sizes have a few standard sizes, bottom brackets are almost all the same sizes, headsets have a few standard sizes. I have a mountain bike from 1995 that I've put a brand new stem on because the headsets are the same size as they were in 1995.