News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Tim Cook memo: line by line by tripzilch on Saturday August 25, 2012 @11:33AM (#4432306)
Fine. I got that. The patent, however, describes the most obvious and straight forward algorithm to implement pinch-to-zoom on a touch-screen.

Of course you can't (officially) patent algorithms either (unless they're sufficiently technical, like MP3 and LZW).

It seems what you're avoiding to state clearly, is what exactly you believe this patent does cover, then. What is it?

Is it that Samsung shouldn't have used a touch screen on a smartphone if they also wanted to implement pinch-to-zoom? Because that's still absurd.

Really, I asked an honest question, and all you say is that's not what the patent covers and it's disinformation--well I was asking wasn't I? So enlighten us, what is the non-trivial bit that the patent covers??

Re:The Tim Cook memo: line by line by nirvana on Saturday August 25, 2012 @11:37AM (#4432317)
I did answer your question. Nobody can patent "pinch to zoom" such that nobody else can use it. The question comes from a misunderstanding of the situation and the patent.

I've met this method of arguing before and consider it a trap. "I think its this, prove me wrong!" In my experience, no amount of research on my part will meet the burden of your opinion.

If you want to argue that the claim is trivial, please, feel free to do the research and quote the patent yourself. Your speculation about what the patent covers is not compelling.

Constantly on this page-- and it appears that this has happened 50-100 times, people have asserted that the patent covers the "right" to use the feature and not the invention.

In fact, the entire basis of the anti-patent movement is grounded in that falsehood.

Thank you for acknowledging that it is false, that was my only issue (because debating specific patents applicability is far more technical of a discussion than you can have in an ideologically driven site like this.)

Re:The Tim Cook memo: line by line by learc83 on Saturday August 25, 2012 @12:01PM (#4432374)
I've read the patent and while you are technically correct, the effect of the patent is to grant them a monopoly on the feature pinch-to-zoom on a smartphone with a touch interface.

The end result is that no one else can implement pinch to zoom on a smart phone.

The patent is also overly broad in that it covers all multi-touch touch screen devices. So that whether I use an infrared overlay or a capacitive screen it is still covered.

Re:The Tim Cook memo: line by line by enraged_camel on Saturday August 25, 2012 @12:53PM (#4432521)
No one else can implement pinch to zoom, so what? Is pinching the only way, or even the best way to zoom? It may seem like it is the best and most obvious way right now but that is only because Apple popularized it and made it ubiquitous. In the future someone may (gasp) innovate and come up with a better solution, that would in hindsight seem even more obvious.
Re:The Tim Cook memo: line by line by learc83 on Saturday August 25, 2012 @01:28PM (#4432598)
Did you read what I was replying to?
Re:The Tim Cook memo: line by line by tripzilch on Saturday August 25, 2012 @11:46AM (#4432337)
And so we leave this discussion without anyone becoming any wiser. Not me, not other people reading this, not you.
Re:The Tim Cook memo: line by line by KirinDave on Saturday August 25, 2012 @01:44PM (#4432649)
I'm not sure about you, but I've seen a fascinating display of apologizing for the patent system. People have been staunchly repeating what it should do as opposed to what is actually happening in practice.

I've also watched a series of curious arguments revolving around the assertion that patent somehow protect small business which are innovation; as if big companies won't dredge up incredibly expensive patents from purchased portfolios to force licence agreements.

I short, I've learned that the average software & design patent proponent really is as disingenuous and intellectually bankrupt as I have suspected... at least this venue.