Re:The Tim Cook memo: line by line
by gnaffle on Saturday August 25, 2012 @08:32AM
(#4431883)
Nobody are claiming Apple invented phones with big screens.
But you have to be pretty blind to not see that iPhone was a revolution in the smartphone market, which had barely seen any user interface innovation in 10 years prior to that.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I'm pretty sure this was a patent infringement lawsuit, so the statement that the "iPhone was a revolution" is irrelevant. Apple won a claim against Samsung for mimicking "bounce back" behavior among other patents.
Hopefully pull-to-refresh isn't patented. I'm not about to look either lest I be found willfully infringing.
Pull to refresh is patented by Twitter, and Apple has bought a license (apparently, since it'll apparently be implemented in iOS 6).
>Apple won a claim against Samsung for mimicking "bounce back" behavior
False. Patents don't cover features. Patents cover inventions. Apple won against samsung for copying apple's solution for how to implement a feature. Not for having that feature.
This misrepresentation trivializes the nature of the patents and is ideologically driven. Don't fall for it.
If you disagree, try reading the patent.