Re:Miguel de Icaza on Samsung v Apple
by mrich on Saturday August 25, 2012 @03:03AM
(#4431325)
A sane voice. Trademark/copyright is enough to protect your product, only in rare cases should a patent be awarded for an algorithm (think RSA).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Miguel de Icaza on Samsung v Apple
by josephlord on Saturday August 25, 2012 @03:58AM
(#4431416)
RSA is more clearly maths (which should be unpatentable) than a UI patent like the scroll bounce which is defined by an imperative if this then do that process and directly affects the world state (by causing light to be projected into it).
I think for software patents do more harm than good but it is incredibly hard and dangerous to try to carve out special rules to keep the few good ones (even if we could agree on which those are).
Re:Miguel de Icaza on Samsung v Apple
by darkestkhan on Saturday August 25, 2012 @04:36AM
(#4431485)
There shouldn't be any patents for algorithms - algorithms are math, and math is not patentable.
Math is all prior art!
Mechanical diagrams are also math.