Have you ever used Windows Phone or WebOS? I assure you, they are not 'bad'.
Obviously, the point of contention here is with the design of the phones themselves, and how similar they look and feel to consumers. In that argument, the phones that have supported WebOS, Blackberry, and the WindowsOS have a lower quality overall, and I like WebOS. I'm talking about hardware, durability, and application ecosystem. This is my claim that smartphones of these types are 'bad'. The iPhone and Android would not be as popular if they were similar to the older Blackberry phones.
I think the competition has been good for all involved, but revisionism fails to tell the real story.
The hardware for Windows Phone and Web OS might have sucked, but the OS's are quite nice in my opinion. I would seriously consider either of those two over an iPhone if they (well WP at least) had better hardware.
Regarding the Blackberry, well, I don't have any defence for them.
Is suggestion that these are "bad smartphones" coming from their lack of sales? This is a false dichotomy. If not - please provide data that suggests otherwise (rather than your own heavily influenced personal opinion either).
It is not the phones or OS that makes IOS outsell the other companies mentioned - It is the apps and the marketing.
So nobody buys an iPhone because of how responsive iOS is or how well the iPhone is designed? Give me a break.
Also, it's "iOS". IOS is the Cisco router OS.
Windows must be superior in every way because it sells more, the other OSes are just bad?
How is that my metric? I said it's ludicrous to assume nobody buys an iPhone because of the design or the OS, it's always because of the apps.
I never said word one about number of units sold, I have no idea what you're talking about right now.
My argument is that these smartphones are 'bad' in the same way that IE is a 'bad' browser in the eyes of most users in comparison to Chrome, Firefox, Opera, and Safari. However, I can't just assume that IF IE had the apps and app developers as the Chrome and FF that everything would change. There's something to be said about context, reputation, and history.
However, I'll concede that calling thse smartphones 'bad' is ambiguous and seems to imply a false dichotomy. The point was that it is kind of ridiculous to point to products with a bad reputation for developers or users (regardless of the reality of their quality) as a shining example of how Samsung didn't have to copy Apple. I agree that they didn't, but those aren't good examples.
Ok sure, but why did you cite a bunch of bad smartphones to validate your point?