Re:Canyon.mid
by timewizard on Sunday June 15, 2025 @07:06PM
(#44285546)
I can play the guitar parts on a banjo but it ain't going to sound right.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
In 1900, QRS began making piano rolls. By 1920, they had invented a machine to capture piano players directly and over the years QRS captured many including Liberace, George Gershwin, and even Roger Miller playing Autumn Leaves.
QRS is still in business and some of its product lines use Midi conversions of piano rolls and last month I landed a mixed lot with a bunch of those Midi files on 3.5” floppy disks.
I had George Gershwin rocking a Yamaha XG clavichord and Liberace on a Sitar and similar shenanigans.
Re:Canyon.mid
by timewizard on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @12:53AM
(#44295868)
I didn't say it wouldn't sound good. It wouldn't sound right, as in, not what was intended.
In particular, think of how this would play out if you had never heard that song before, would that be what you were after?