News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Language and Image Minus Cognition." Leif Weatherby on LLMs by nfc on Saturday June 14, 2025 @01:03PM (#44277469)
Had a conversation with an LLM (not even a thinking one) about this article. As I am in mobile and have not much time I asked it to summarize some of my views for a comment on HN, this is the result, hope this does not go against HN guidelines :)

Weatherby argues that LLMs challenge traditional ideas of language tied to human cognition, and he promotes a structuralist/dialectical view where meaning arises from systemic relations and oppositions—not just usage or intent. But he misrepresents the “statistical” view by treating it as naive co-occurrence tracking. Modern LLMs (e.g., transformers) don’t just count— they build complex, high-dimensional structures where meaning emerges from position in a learned space. So ironically, these statistical systems end up modeling something very close to the structuralist “totality” he champions. The divide isn't as clear as he suggests.

Re:"Language and Image Minus Cognition." Leif Weatherby on LLMs by dcre on Saturday June 14, 2025 @01:09PM (#44277497)
I don’t know what the guidelines are, but this is not helpful or accurate as a characterization of the interview. If anything, Weatherby is saying exactly what you say he gets wrong: “LLMs are not the total distribution, but they’re a far larger chunk of it than we’ve ever before been able to see or play with.” I am no anti-LLM guy but this is an embarrassing way to use them.
Re:"Language and Image Minus Cognition." Leif Weatherby on LLMs by nfc on Saturday June 14, 2025 @02:05PM (#44277781)
Thank you for your reply, I may have misinterpreted what Weatherby was saying and I admit I did not spend enough time reading it. I've re-skimmed it and think you may be right.

With respect to the use of LLMs for my original comment. I think however that this is a useful use for them. It started a conversation on an article that had not comments on it and helped at least one person (me but hopefully others too) to get a better understanding of what was said (thanks to your comment). But it's not a hill I'm willing to die on, specially after already having been wrong once in this thread :)

Re:"Language and Image Minus Cognition." Leif Weatherby on LLMs by baobun on Saturday June 14, 2025 @02:12PM (#44277806)
I find it disrespectful and selfish to expect thousands of people to read and analyze a comment you can't bother to write yourself.

You may have been helped in this situation but you've amortized it with great interest amongst all of us.

Re:"Language and Image Minus Cognition." Leif Weatherby on LLMs by mrbungie on Saturday June 14, 2025 @02:08PM (#44277790)
You can invoke Poe's law just by reading the article (or not as happens with most cases of honest/unintentional Poe's law) and posting something wrong about it. LLMs are not needed for this use case, we can think and spark discussions by ourselves, that's the whole point of a forum.
Re:"Language and Image Minus Cognition." Leif Weatherby on LLMs by ThrowawayR2 on Saturday June 14, 2025 @03:07PM (#44278141)
Please do not post LLM generated summaries. The HN moderation team has said in the past that "HN has never allowed bots or generated comments." in response to a question about ChatGPT generated postings: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33950747
Re:"Language and Image Minus Cognition." Leif Weatherby on LLMs by gessha on Saturday June 14, 2025 @02:20PM (#44277838)
If I wanted an LLM summary, I would’ve plugged the link into an LLM. Please don’t pollute the commons.
Re:"Language and Image Minus Cognition." Leif Weatherby on LLMs by layer8 on Saturday June 14, 2025 @03:19PM (#44278215)
They didn’t summarize the article, they used an LLM to summarize their thoughts on the article.
Re:"Language and Image Minus Cognition." Leif Weatherby on LLMs by baobun on Saturday June 14, 2025 @04:36PM (#44278659)
Sounds closer to an LLM summary of their views on the conclusion of the LLM conversation session about the LLM summary of the article...

Noise without insight, either way.