News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Left-Pad (2024) by nindalf on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @06:14PM (#44252407)
He had already given everyone a license to use his software. That’s what FOSS software is - the users are granted a license to use the software and it can’t be revoked, even if the author is throwing a tantrum.
Re:Left-Pad (2024) by IggleSniggle on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @06:42PM (#44252604)
Sure, but that license doesn't include the requirement to host in perpetuity, and anyway, I wouldn't expect a hobbyist to need to worry about this. If I decide to make my gamer-profile private / offline or something and that breaks your crawler, even though I previously granted unrestricted public access to that data, that's really not my problem.
Re:Left-Pad (2024) by nindalf on Thursday June 12, 2025 @04:02AM (#44255170)
Let’s not pretend he was hosting the software. Npm was.

No software developer or organisation will use a software repository that allows deletion of packages. That’s why it’s not a thing anymore.

If you think this “right” should exist, that’s a market niche for you to exploit. But you won’t, will you? Because like I said, no user wants this.

Re:Left-Pad (2024) by IggleSniggle on Thursday June 12, 2025 @08:02AM (#44256712)
??? I didn't say anybody using npm wants this. I'm saying npm had the wrong policy around deletion, that npm could have handled the situation differently, and also that Azer not knowing or caring about the effects of removing the package doesn't make him an asshole or even negligent (although it also doesn't mean he ISNT an asshole; that's a separate matter).

The point is that Azer didn't owe anybody anything; not even to know what he was doing. npm did.

That said, I'm glad the wake-up call came in such a relatively benign way.