News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US appeals court rules in favor of patenting genes by doktrin on Thursday August 23, 2012 @12:39PM (#4423346)
A 2-1 panel of the U.S. Federal Circuit Court of Appeals in Washington, D.C., on Thursday upheld the biotechnology company's right to patent "isolated" genes known as BRCA1 and BRCA2, which account for most inherited forms of breast and ovarian cancers.

...Circuit Judge Alan Lourie, writing for the court majority, said, "Everything and everyone comes from nature, following its laws, but the compositions here are not natural products. They are the products of man, albeit following, as all materials do, laws of nature."

I completely fail to see how [gene] compositions are the "product of man". What am I missing?

Re:US appeals court rules in favor of patenting genes by astine on Thursday August 23, 2012 @12:58PM (#4423455)
If human beings composed said genes, ie. through a splice or more involved process, then said composition is indeed a product of man because it was brought about through deliberate human effort and did not exist before. There are many ethical concerns with patented genes, but whether or not artificial gene composition are products of man seems pretty clear to me.

By way of analogy, rock formations occur naturally, but when a person deliberately carves or arranges the rocks, as in a primitive building or in a statue, it becomes artificial, even if it resembles something that could appear in nature. The same logic would apply here. The problem, as I see it, is that we might end up patenting real people's genes and that could lead to real trouble.

Re:US appeals court rules in favor of patenting genes by doktrin on Thursday August 23, 2012 @01:09PM (#4423533)
After doing some additional reading, I can now see what the basis for the pro-patent argument is. However, I disagree with it as I'm struggling with the concept of "because we touched it, it's now different".

Below is a description, from a patent law blog, of the change that occurs during the gene isolation :

"To be clear, the change in the molecule that the court is discussing is that the isolated DNA molecule is cleaved from the larger chromosomal DNA molecule by enzymatically cutting it off at each end and slightly altering the terminal amino acid groups." [1]

From the same link, one judge ruled this as akin to plucking a leaf from a tree. While the analogy is simplistic - how is it [conceptually] different?

Judge rulings below :

Judge Bryson [minority] :

[E]xtracting a gene is akin to snapping a leaf from a tree. Like a gene, a leaf has a natural starting and stopping point. It buds during spring from the same place that it breaks off and falls during autumn. Yet prematurely plucking the leaf would not turn it into a human-made invention. That would remain true if there were minor differences between the plucked leaf and the fallen autumn leaf, unless those differences imparted "markedly different characteristics" to the plucked leaf.

Louie & Moore [majority ruling] :

It is also important to dispute the dissent's analogy to snapping a leaf from a tree. With respect, no one could contemplate that snapping a leaf from a tree would be worthy of a patent, whereas isolating genes to provide useful diagnostic tools and medicines is surely what the patent laws are intended to encourage and protect. Snapping a leaf from a tree is a physical separation, easily done by anyone. Creating a new chemical entity is the work of human transformation, requiring skill, knowledge, and effort.

[1]http://www.patentlyo.com/patent/2012/08/gene-patent-debate-c...

Re:US appeals court rules in favor of patenting genes by jrl on Thursday August 23, 2012 @02:56PM (#4424201)
"It is also important to dispute the dissent's analogy to snapping a leaf from a tree. With respect, no one could contemplate that snapping a leaf from a tree would be worthy of a patent, whereas isolating genes to provide useful diagnostic tools and medicines is surely what the patent laws are intended to encourage and protect. Snapping a leaf from a tree is a physical separation, easily done by anyone. Creating a new chemical entity is the work of human transformation, requiring skill, knowledge, and effort."

They're not creating a new chemical entity. The gene was created by evolution (natural selection, genetic drift, mutation) millions of years ago. The DNA sequence existed and performed its function long before any human began studying it. Furthermore, such information could already be found isolated in the form of mRNA, which contains the same information as the DNA gene (with the thymines replaced by uracils). Ultimately, what really matters for the function of the cell and even the diagnostic method is the information coded in the DNA, RNA, or protein. You are simply using a different alphabet to represent the same thing. And because the information was designed by nature, it shouldn't be patentable.

Nearly all experiments require you to modify what you're observing in order to measure it. That's why I feel the argument asserting that because you "modify" something makes it susceptible to patent protection is weak. If I combine water with some powder and sell it, I can patent the final product or maybe even the process to make it, but not the water. Water was present before I had the idea. BRCA1 was there before we had the idea of linking it to cancer, it's a substance just like water.

The troubling thing in this case is there's not even a modification involved. Cutting a DNA segment from the chromosome doesn't alter its sequence. In fact, separating DNA pieces happens routinely during recombination.

The problem is that they're not only protecting the diagnostic tool like the majority ruling says, they're claiming ownership of a chemical substance present in all humans that was invented by nature. I would support patenting the DNA sequencing method they used, but never the gene itself.

Re:US appeals court rules in favor of patenting genes by gbladeCL on Thursday August 23, 2012 @02:28PM (#4424041)
Wouldn't the chemical isolation of elements, as done in the 18th and 19th centuries, be a better analogy? Doing so required a human transformation, requiring skill, knowledge, and effort, yet would anyone patent an element? We are still creating new heavy elements in particle accelerators; are those patentable?

If the argument is that the gene is modified in its isolation by changing the terminating amino acids, we could extend the analogy to include changes to the electron shell of an element brought about by chemical processes.

Re:US appeals court rules in favor of patenting genes by astine on Thursday August 23, 2012 @01:35PM (#4423714)
See, this is not a field I'm really involved in, so I can't comment on the particulars. Case in point: what you describe is the isolation of a preexisting gene, rather than the creation of a new one, which is different from what I was thinking of.

But if the copyright is on the isolated gene, then I think the logic would follow that the copyright wouldn't apply to instances of the gene that haven't been isolated. Ie, plucking a leaf wouldn't allow you copyright leaves, but would allow you to copyright plucked leaves. (Which is stupid, but for different reasons.)

Re:US appeals court rules in favor of patenting genes by doktrin on Thursday August 23, 2012 @01:55PM (#4423861)
If I understand correctly, it's a pre-existing gene that is modified by its removal / isolation. It appears to be an incredibly subtle change that in no way alters the fundamental characteristics of the gene itself.

So yes, by extension they would hold no copyright over the genes in a given person's body, but it might extend to cover any tests or work that is done with those genes in the body - such as cancer screening tests.

Re:US appeals court rules in favor of patenting genes by rayiner on Thursday August 23, 2012 @02:26PM (#4424026)
We're talking about patents not copyrights...
Re:US appeals court rules in favor of patenting genes by mbreese on Thursday August 23, 2012 @01:25PM (#4423655)
the isolated DNA molecule is cleaved from the larger chromosomal DNA molecule by enzymatically cutting it off at each end and slightly altering the terminal amino acid groups

If that's what they patented, then I think we're all in the clear... DNA doesn't have amino acids. Whew! And here I thought a court might have made a terrible mistake in a ruling about something that they didn't fully understand.

Re:US appeals court rules in favor of patenting genes by rayiner on Thursday August 23, 2012 @02:26PM (#4424025)
The "amino acids" language is from the blogger, not the opinion. Also, without trying to defend the decision--the judge who wrote the opinion (Alan Lourie) has a PhD in chemistry and worked as a chemist and scientist for Monsanto and Wyeth.
Re:US appeals court rules in favor of patenting genes by doktrin on Thursday August 23, 2012 @02:52PM (#4424176)
This is an interesting point, and this very background may have found its way into the ruling. Specifically, that the judge has a background in chemistry and directly speaks to the difference in perspective between biologists and chemists :

"We recognize that biologists may think of molecules in terms of their uses, but genes are in fact materials having a chemical nature and, as such, are best described in patents by their structures rather than by their functions" [1]

The blogger goes on to state in more plain terms :

"In other words, this ruling affirms that molecular biology is, in fact, chemistry, if you want to look at it that way."

[1]http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/2012/08/17/the_myriad_g...

Re:US appeals court rules in favor of patenting genes by mbreese on Thursday August 23, 2012 @02:56PM (#4424203)
This makes perfect sense... I could easily see how a chemist could come to one conclusion, whereas a biologist would come to a completely different conclusion. In this case, I think the judge's chemistry training actually worked against him.
Re:US appeals court rules in favor of patenting genes by lifeisstillgood on Thursday August 23, 2012 @01:05PM (#4423504)
I think one of the weaknesses is in replication - the process of replicating genes is most certainly not a product of man.

So if a rock carved into a primitive statue is mine, and if rock could naturally replicate, split into two, would the second rock which I had no hand in creating, still be my product? And the third?

Re:US appeals court rules in favor of patenting genes by astine on Thursday August 23, 2012 @01:21PM (#4423626)
I think it would. If the original statue was your product and the new statues would only have come into existence because of your original, then the criteria for copyright would still apply. The reason is that copyright is meant to give creators some legal control over stuff which is liable to be copied without his control.

Of course, there are a lot more difficulties in copyrighted genes than in other copyrighted works, but I think that is due to the failure of the copyright system to take into account the unique nature of genes rather than the ineligibility of genes for copyright as the law stands.

I suspect that what will happen is that the genes will remain copyrightable and the law will be modified to account for the unique dangers copyrighted genes present, likely through limiting the power copyright holders possess over them.

Re:US appeals court rules in favor of patenting genes by rorrr on Thursday August 23, 2012 @02:10PM (#4423937)
Except that the company that tries to patent BRCA gene has nothing to do with its "carving". Your analogy doesn't work.
Re:US appeals court rules in favor of patenting genes by dkroy on Thursday August 23, 2012 @01:20PM (#4423617)
I feel that this is similar to patenting genetically modified seeds, which has already been happening for awhile.