Re:An IP lawyer on patents, trolls, and entrepreneurship
by tankbot on Thursday August 23, 2012 @11:51AM
(#4423022)
Hah! That image is great. Oddly enough though, my initial reaction is to support Apple's claim for slide to unlock but scoff at them for "rounded corners."
I'm not sure why, I guess because rounded corners seem so obvious while slide to unlock is pretty ingenious, if derivative.
Re:An IP lawyer on patents, trolls, and entrepreneurship
by SkyMarshal on Thursday August 23, 2012 @12:31PM
(#4423290)
Rounded corners are obvious. Steve Jobs himself famously demonstrated prior art:
Re:An IP lawyer on patents, trolls, and entrepreneurship
by neya on Thursday August 23, 2012 @12:46PM
(#4423386)
Yeah I can understand your point. Actually, design conclusions should never be patent-able in my opinion. The rounded corners, more than just design is an obvious conclusion, no matter what you do, because sharp edges tend to chip off when dropped off from great heights, so you need a smooth radius in the corners to prevent that from happening.
Another patent war I can foresee (maybe in the future), that involves an obvious design conclusion is the Wheel hub motor (which is the future for most electric cars). Google for 'Protean Electric', these guys have patented an obvious design conclusion for a wheel hub motor. Something like Apple did.
I'm reminded of this funny image that was trending on G+ recently: http://phandroid.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/10...