News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Building supercomputers for autocrats probably isn't good... by credit_guy on Sunday June 08, 2025 @09:03PM (#44220562)
No, I'm not talking about abdication of responsibility. I'm talking about modesty. It is very appealing to think you know better than other people. That we know how a society should be governed, and we are able to label another country as totalitarian, or undemocratic, or illiberal, or such. But looking around the world, you can see that a lot of evil is perpetrated exactly by people who think they know better than everyone else. Osama bin Laden himself thought that what he was doing was for the advancement of good over evil, and a lot of his followers thought the same.

A lot of the people reading Hacker News right now think they have a better solution for the societal problems of the UAE. I personally have no idea about what's going on over there. But let's say that I'm in charge of the business decisions at Open AI. Should I start thinking that I know a way to solve their problems, and part of that way is for my company to apply some form of AI embargo on them? Or should I simply know my limitations, and restrict my judgment to the matters I am familiar with.

"Abdication of responsibility". What grand words. Why exactly has Open AI a responsibility to guide the UAE towards a better future? And, more importantly, why should Open AI feel confident that they know what is better for the UAE?

Re:Building supercomputers for autocrats probably isn't good... by cyberax on Sunday June 08, 2025 @09:55PM (#44220839)
> Why exactly has Open AI a responsibility to guide the UAE towards a better future?

OpenAI is not responsible for UAE government. However, it's responsible for its own actions, and for their easily predictable consequences.

Re:Building supercomputers for autocrats probably isn't good... by ImPostingOnHN on Monday June 09, 2025 @01:10AM (#44221581)
> I'm talking about modesty.

And I am talking about not doing bad things, which includes helping others do bad things.

> It is very appealing to think you know better than other people.

Not really. Responsibility, principles, and morality are work. It's far more appealing to claim they are someone else's job, dispense with them, turn your brain off, and do whatever feels good.

> A lot of the people reading Hacker News right now think they have a better solution for the societal problems of the UAE.

With all due respect, the percentage of HackerNews readers who are thinking about the UAE right now can be counted on one hand. This discussion is about generalities: Don't help people do bad stuff.

You're arguing about what's bad, and what isn't, and who decides. Interesting topic (perhaps for someone else or for another time)! Would you help someone do something which you think is bad?

Re:Building supercomputers for autocrats probably isn't good... by credit_guy on Monday June 09, 2025 @12:50PM (#44226403)
> Would you help someone do something which you think is bad?

I wouldn’t. But this is not the question here. The question here is if I would give someone a powerful tool that can be used for good, for neutral or for bad things, if I believe that there is a good chance it will be used for bad things. That puts a lot of responsibility on me to get into the business of predicting bad behavior.

Re:Building supercomputers for autocrats probably isn't good... by ImPostingOnHN on Monday June 09, 2025 @08:04PM (#44231042)
> That puts a lot of responsibility on me to get into the business of predicting bad behavior.

Not a ton: you don't need to come up with a numerical probability, and erring on the side of caution is just fine.

That said, I think that IS the question here. If you think it's good or even neutral to give autocrats technology which they almost certainly will use for autocracy (even if they do other things with it), then this isn't a moral dilemma you need concern yourself with.

Re:Building supercomputers for autocrats probably isn't good... by credit_guy on Monday June 09, 2025 @09:54PM (#44231691)
> If you think it's good or even neutral to give autocrats technology which they almost certainly will use for autocracy (even if they do other things with it), then this isn't a moral dilemma you need concern yourself with.

In the West, we have the attitude that autocracy is bad, if only autocrats were not helped by us, they'll fall and they'll be replaced by democracy, and perhaps by crowds singing in unison Beetles' "Imagine". In reality, democracy is a very unlikely outcome of a dictator being toppled. The top 2 outcomes, by miles and miles, are 1. the dictator is replaced by another dictator and 2. the dictator is replaced by some weak pseudo-state like Somalia, Lebanon or Yemen.

I think we should re-calibrate our self-confidence that we know what's best for others. As I said, I have no idea who is governing the UAE, but I know that it's much easier to criticize them than to come with a realistic better alternative.

Re:Building supercomputers for autocrats probably isn't good... by ImPostingOnHN on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @12:07AM (#44244113)
> In the West, we have the attitude that autocracy is bad

Many other places, too. Obviously it's not a universal thing: every sufficiently large group of people has fans of autocracy.

The rest of your post kind of veers off-topic, so remember we're talking about individual people's decision to not work on something based on their own judgements. I don't think it's worth arguing at them that their judgements are wrongly made.

Again, If you think it's good or even neutral to give autocrats technology which they almost certainly will use for autocracy (even if they do other things with it), then this isn't a moral dilemma you need concern yourself with. Nobody is trying to convince you personally to change your mind, so as long as you don't try to change theirs, you do not need to be defensive.

> I think we should re-calibrate our self-confidence that we know what's best for others.

I think a good place for you to start with this, would be to be less confident that you know what's best for others who are deciding whether to empower autocrats. It's much easier for you to criticize them and their decision, than to come with a realistic, better alternative.

Re:Building supercomputers for autocrats probably isn't good... by credit_guy on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @08:26PM (#44253256)
You've got it backwards. Open AI wants to do business with the UAE. A lot of the people here think this is bad, and you are one of them. I am saying: Open AI is engaging in business that is legal as far as the US laws are involved, because the UAE are not under sanctions. We (the US) are a democracy, and the US government acts as a representative of our collective will. As a democracy we decided, through our representatives, that is ok to do business with the UAE, otherwise we'd have sanctions on them. I am ok with that, and I was pointing out that private businesses should concern themselves with doing business, and the State Department should be trusted with making the value decision if a regime is autocratic enough that the US wants to put is on its sanctions list.

You think for some reason that this type of position is one of arrogance. That I should show modesty and let people, such as yourself, criticize Open AI for getting in bed with autocrats. And if myself I have no problem with autocrats, then I should just keep out of this, because nobody around here asked for my opinion.

But this is very backward. When Jesus said that only those who never wronged in their life should throw a stone, one could retort that only people who never wronged should tell other people what to do with the stones they find on the street. Does that type of argument make sense to you?

Re:Building supercomputers for autocrats probably isn't good... by ImPostingOnHN on Friday June 13, 2025 @01:46PM (#44270573)
you're confusing what is legal with what is moral – the two dimensions are orthogonal

importantly, we are not forced to adopt the morality of 1 particular government, out of hundreds of thousands – this is an appeal to authority (and not even a good authority)

if someone thinks that empowering autocrats is immoral, even if it's not illegal, then it is indeed arrogance to say that you have decided their morality is wrong

> You think for some reason... That I should show modesty and let people, such as yourself, criticize Open AI for getting in bed with autocrats

not really: modesty in judging others was your suggestion. you can stand by your suggestion or not, but you don't have the power to "let" or not "let" anybody criticize autocrats or their enablers

remember here: them criticizing autocrats and their enablers, is equally valid to you criticizing them for their criticism; which is equally valid to others criticizing you for criticizing their criticism; etc... we could keep going, but as you undoubtedly see, there is no good discussion to be had in the meta-direction of criticizing criticism, rather than directly addressing the issues raised in the initial critique

as for the jesus analogy: I wish I could follow it, but I could not, likely due to a failing on my part (I'm not familiar with jesus) -- would you mind rephrasing the point as a non-analogy (directly)? perhaps an analogy won't be necessary because the message is clear!

Re:Building supercomputers for autocrats probably isn't good... by int_19h on Monday June 09, 2025 @11:26AM (#44225470)
> should I simply know my limitations, and restrict my judgment to the matters I am familiar with

Sure, but the course of action that best reflects this is to not get involved in such business at all (because you just admitted that you're incapable of judging its consequences).