Re:Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts
by peterfirefly on Saturday June 07, 2025 @04:46PM
(#44212536)
It was not out of thin air. There's a reason why the impeachment process is in the Constitution -- and why it's perfectly normal for countries to have Parliamental Immunity and processes quite similar to the US impeachment for government ministers.
Re:Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts
by cosmicgadget on Saturday June 07, 2025 @05:57PM
(#44212966)
We have legislative immunity called the speech and debate clause. It doesn't shield lawmakers from other crimes, nor should it, and it certainly doesn't imply some sort of expansive executive immunity.
The founders were rebelling agaisnt an untouchable executive, remember?
Re:Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts
by voidfunc on Saturday June 07, 2025 @07:23PM
(#44213369)
If the founders thought it was so important the President not have immunity from all crimes they would have written it such rather than leaving it to interpretation.
Re:Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts
by dragonwriter on Saturday June 07, 2025 @07:31PM
(#44213396)
> If the founders thought it was so important the President not have immunity from all crimes they would have written it such
They did; by writing in explicit immunities for some constitutional officers for certain activities, they implicitly rejected other immunities for those and other constitutional officers, by the legal principle “expressio unius est exclusio alterius”.
Re:Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts
by wqaatwt on Sunday June 08, 2025 @02:56AM
(#44215126)
That the opposite of how laws work..
Re:Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts
by voidfunc on Tuesday June 10, 2025 @12:16PM
(#44238562)
Opposite of common law, but exactly how the Constitution works.
Re:Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts
by wqaatwt on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @01:47AM
(#44244549)
Well if the constitution does not explicitly grant a certain right it can’t just appear out of nowhere? At this point it’s about the “spirit” of the constitution not what is in the document itself since there is no mention of presidential immunity.
On the other hand it does grant the members of congress immunity under certain circumstances so it’s unlikely they just forgot about the president when writing it.
Re:Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts
by nradov on Saturday June 07, 2025 @04:52PM
(#44212577)
This contract dispute has nothing to do with Presidential immunity from criminal prosecution for official acts. Cancelling SpaceX contracts for political reasons would be wrong but not criminal.
Re:Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts
by catlifeonmars on Saturday June 07, 2025 @05:38PM
(#44212856)
The point is we won’t find out because presidential immunity also protects against discovery. Cases that previously could have been decided on the merits won’t even make it to adjudication.
Re:Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts
by nradov on Saturday June 07, 2025 @08:05PM
(#44213543)
No, that's not how it works. The Trump v. United States case had no bearing on civil discovery.
Re:Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts
by cosmicgadget on Saturday June 07, 2025 @08:56PM
(#44213790)
What about Nixon?
All of this is enabled by the completely illegitimate Supreme Court decision that made the president a god-king by inventing out of thin air the concept of "presidential immunity".
Not only is the scope of "official duties" so broad to make prosseuction next to impossible but the majority went out of its way to say you can't even examine the communications between the president and the DoJ.