Re:Ask HN : What's the meanest thing that has been said abou...
by kirubakaran on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @01:41PM
(#442048)
I never understood why people were doing that. Many Reddit comments about your essays were extremely vicious.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Ask HN : What's the meanest thing that has been said abou...
by pg on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @02:13PM
(#442099)
I think the fundamental problem is that writing essays seems presumptuous to a lot of people. They're used to the old print media model in which the only people who got to publish essays were credentialled experts in whatever they were about. That restriction is now gone. Online anyone can publish whatever they want. But I think it still seems to a lot of people that anyone using the essay form is implicitly claiming some kind of authority.
The right approach, obviously, is to judge an essay by what it says instead of who wrote it. I think things will tend to move in that direction. But not too far, because it's more work.
Re:Ask HN : What's the meanest thing that has been said abou...
by kirubakaran on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @02:31PM
(#442126)
Yes, you mentioned that in http://www.paulgraham.com/newthings.html
That explains the dismissive comments. The angry and really mean ones can be explained perhaps as people feeling threatened for whatever reason?
Re:Ask HN : What's the meanest thing that has been said abou...
by SwellJoe on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @04:32PM
(#442334)
When in doubt, Gabriel's Greater Internet Fuckwad theory probably applies: http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2004/03/19/
Re:Ask HN : What's the meanest thing that has been said abou...
by kirubakaran on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @05:01PM
(#442373)
I agree, but why do they do that?
Re:Ask HN : What's the meanest thing that has been said abou...
by SwellJoe on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @07:30PM
(#442515)
I dunno. I figured I'd done my job in providing a link to a funny picture on the Internet. If you ask me any more hard questions, you're gonna get a picture of a cat fixing a computer. I don't think either of us really wants that to happen.
Re:Ask HN : What's the meanest thing that has been said abou...
by trapper on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @05:19PM
(#442387)
You should try publishing under a different name next time and see what the response is. It would be an interesting experiment.
Re:Ask HN : What's the meanest thing that has been said abou...
by kirubakaran on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @06:34PM
(#442445)
If he doesn't put a lot of effort into hiding his writing style, it should be pretty easy to tell.
Re:Ask HN : What's the meanest thing that has been said abou...
by trapper on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @07:40PM
(#442528)
I'd like to think I could tell as well, but only a trial would let us test your hypothesis.
Re:Ask HN : What's the meanest thing that has been said abou...
by marcell on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @07:45PM
(#442535)
Sometimes, an article is boring enough and the writer is interesting enough that the only logical thing to comment on is the writer.
Re:Ask HN : What's the meanest thing that has been said abou...
by rokhayakebe on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @02:03PM
(#442086)
Human nature. They will love you first. Hate you second. And when you are gone, they will love you again, claiming that all those things you wrote/said were prophecies, visions.