Re:After court order, OpenAI is now preserving all ChatGPT u...
by piombisallow on Thursday June 05, 2025 @10:17AM
(#44191947)
"public interest" is a much more ambiguous thing than the written law
Re:After court order, OpenAI is now preserving all ChatGPT u...
by otterley on Thursday June 05, 2025 @10:25AM
(#44192039)
Yes. And, that's why both sides will make their cases to the court as to whether the public interest is served by an injunction, and then the court will make a decision based on who made the best argument.
The law is not a deterministic computer program. It’s a complex body of overlapping work and the courts are specifically chartered to use judgement. That’s why briefs from two parties in a dispute will often cite different laws and precedents.
For instance, Winter v. NRDC specifically says that courts must consider whether an injunction is in the public interest.