Re:A proposal to restrict sites from accessing a users' loca...
by oasisbob on Thursday June 05, 2025 @12:50PM
(#44193378)
"No true Scotsman allows GETs with side effects" is not a strong argument
It's not just HTTP where this is a problem. There are enough http-ish protocols where protocol smuggling confusion is a risk. It's possible to send chimeric HTTP requests at devices which then interpret them as a protocol other than http.
While it clearly isn't a hard guarantee, in practice it does seem to generally work as these have been known issues without apparent massive exploits for decades. That CORS restrictions block probing (no response provided) does help makes this all significantly more difficult.