News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AGI Is Not Multimodal by patrickscoleman on Wednesday June 04, 2025 @12:53PM (#44182794)
It feels like some of the comments are responding to the title, not the contents of the article.

Maybe a more descriptive but longer title would be: AGI will work with multimodal inputs and outputs embedded in a physical environment rather than a frankenstein combination of single-modal models (what today is called multimodal) and throwing more computational resources at the problem (scale maximalism) will be improved with thoughtful theoretical approaches to data and training.

Re:AGI Is Not Multimodal by robwwilliams on Wednesday June 04, 2025 @03:25PM (#44184525)
Interesting article but incomplete in important ways. Yes correct that embodiment and free-form interactions are critical to moving toward AGI, but what is likely much more important are supervisory meta-systems (yet another module) that enable self-control of attention with a balance integration of intrinsic goals with extrinsic perturbations. It is this nominally simple self-recursive control of attention that is what I regard as the missing ingredient.
Re:AGI Is Not Multimodal by groby_b on Wednesday June 04, 2025 @10:09PM (#44187667)
Possibly. Meta's HPT work sidesteps that issue neatly. Will it lead to AGI? Who the heck knows, but it does not need a meta system for that control.
Re:AGI Is Not Multimodal by robwwilliams on Saturday June 07, 2025 @01:55PM (#44211307)
Yep good point. One could argue about whether this is more a terminological distinction or a difference architecture. Certain shared objectives.
Re:AGI Is Not Multimodal by tedivm on Wednesday June 04, 2025 @01:10PM (#44183009)
Yeah, I found this article to be fascinating and there's a lot of important stuff in it. It really does feel like more people stopped at the title and missed the meat of it.

I know this is a very long article compared to a lot of things posted here, but it really is worth a thorough read.

Re:AGI Is Not Multimodal by dirtyhippiefree on Wednesday June 04, 2025 @01:04PM (#44182914)
Agreed, but most people are likely to look at the long title and say TL;DR…
Re:AGI Is Not Multimodal by Hugsun on Thursday June 05, 2025 @04:49AM (#44189723)
I discovered that this is very common when posting a long article about LLM reasoning. Half the comments spoke of the exact things in the article as if they were original ideas.