Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor
by icebraining on Wednesday August 22, 2012 @12:15PM
(#4418103)
Do you mean atheist as in, not agnostic? Because the two are not the same; Dawkins, for example, is an agnostic atheist, since he doesn't claim to know for sure.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor
by recycleme on Wednesday August 22, 2012 @12:35PM
(#4418208)
Yup, IIRC, in the God Delusion, Dawkins talks about a belief spectrum. The spectrum ranges from 1 thru 7 where 1 is a strong theist who believes and knows there is a God and 7 is a strong Atheist who knows there is no God. Dawkins mentions he is a 6 (low probability of a God, doesn't know for sure but chooses to live on the assumption that there is no God) and leaning toward 7.
Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor
by Kroem3r on Thursday August 23, 2012 @12:53AM
(#4420963)
It's interesting that the discussion is in terms of God exists/doesn't exist. I think that already includes a pretty significant context. It's worth also considering the relevancy of the belief; the degree to which one's beliefs operate within that context. For example, that there is (or maybe there isn't) a guy on some planet somewhere named Booglifoog -- it makes no difference to me -- the question is irrelevant.
It's like skiing in the trees; if you want to succeed at this, focus on the spaces between the trees, not on the trees. Dawkins, for whatever reason, is distinctly focused on the trees.
Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor
by icebraining on Thursday August 23, 2012 @05:06AM
(#4421503)
I had a similar thought when I read about Dawkin's axis (which I didn't know about). It implies either an active embrace or rejection of god - particularly of the abrahamic god - that doesn't make sense to me, as someone who was born in a very non-religious setting.