News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor by polshaw on Wednesday August 22, 2012 @11:27AM (#4417816)
I really hate this trend for describing anything somewhat intellectual as 'autistic'.
Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor by lutusp on Wednesday August 22, 2012 @11:38AM (#4417876)
Yes, but psychologists love it -- it's bread on their table. Anyone sufficiently to the right of the mean I.Q. can be diagnosed on the autism spectrum, and be put into pointless therapy.
Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor by alanctgardner on Wednesday August 22, 2012 @12:24PM (#4418154)
I don't really understand this view of therapy. In my experience, it's something you choose for yourself, because you recognize the need. The odds that you receive a psychiatric evaluation against your will and be compelled into therapy are amazingly slim. Especially for something like 'autism-spectrum' disorders, where the majority of sufferers appear to be high-functioning.
Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor by lutusp on Wednesday August 22, 2012 @01:25PM (#4418446)
> I don't really understand this view of therapy. In my experience, it's something you choose for yourself, because you recognize the need.

That would be nice, but it doesn't reflect reality. In schools, children are frequently given autism spectrum diagnoses against their better interests, or wishes, or the wishes of their parents (but not always -- sometimes parents force these things on their children). But the patient's wishes are often the lowest priority.

Ideally, people would volunteer for therapy solely on issues they choose for themselves. But this isn't how clinical psychology works in modern times. Schools have a vested interest in getting diagnoses, because special-education funds are only available for those with a diagnosis.

The reason Asperger's is being abandoned is because it was applied in exactly the way described above, until everyone realized it was a scam -- even the therapists who benefited the most. Now it's slated for removal from the next edition of the DSM, and further, the diagnosis criteria for autism spectrum is being reworked to prevent another epidemic of nonsense diagnoses such as we have just seen.

> The odds that you receive a psychiatric evaluation against your will and be compelled into therapy are amazingly slim.

On the contrary, it's an everyday occurrence, especially among children, who aren't mature enough to realize that psychologists aren't doctors.

> Especially for something like 'autism-spectrum' disorders, where the majority of sufferers appear to be high-functioning.

Yes, and that is the present problem area -- bogus diagnoses, using vague criteria that can be applied to nearly anyone, with obvious advantages to everyone except the patient.

Mental health professionals, aware that autism spectrum diagnoses are out of control and no longer have any connection to reality, have joined an American Psychological Association task force charged with redefining ASD to stem the tide of nonsense diagnoses. One of those behind the redefinition effort (Dr. Fred Volkmar, director of the Child Study Center at the Yale School of Medicine) says of the diagnosis surge, "We would nip it in the bud."

Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor by huxley on Wednesday August 22, 2012 @03:43PM (#4419182)
You seem to be referring to info and quotes from this NY Times article

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/20/health/research/new-autism...

Dr. Volkmar --who you quoted-- is actually against the redefinition and is arguing that the redefinition hides people who do suffer from genuine conditions.

Here is a Yale interview of Dr. Volkmar that left me with a far different impression than the NY Times article:

http://yalemedicalgroup.org/autism2012

And this:

http://www.yaledailynews.com/news/2012/feb/02/autism-redefin...

Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor by lutusp on Wednesday August 22, 2012 @08:31PM (#4420311)
> Dr. Volkmar --who you quoted-- is actually against the redefinition and is arguing that the redefinition hides people who do suffer from genuine conditions.

So that would be why Volkmar is serving on a task force charged with responsiblity for redefining ASD? That would be why he has been quoted as saying his committee would address the ASD diagnosis epidemic and "nip it in the bud"?

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/20/health/research/new-autism...

Quote: "The changes would narrow the diagnosis so much that it could effectively end the autism surge, said Dr. Fred R. Volkmar, director of the Child Study Center at the Yale School of Medicine and an author of the new analysis of the proposal. “We would nip it in the bud.”" (Emphasis added.)

To make this perfectly clear, Dr. Volkmar is an advocate of this change, and is one of the leaders of the activity.

Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor by charlieflowers on Wednesday August 22, 2012 @01:38PM (#4418528)
"... Asperger's is being abandoned.... Now it's slated for removal from the next edition of the DSM"

REALLY??! Wow. I sure thought I was seeing a bunch of misguided hullabaloo, but I'm surprised to see the "industry" itself is aware of it and addressing it. Do you have a link or any kind of substantiation?

Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor by lutusp on Wednesday August 22, 2012 @01:48PM (#4418577)
> Do you have a link or any kind of substantiation?

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/03/health/03asperger.html?pag...

The above is just one of the many links to this topic -- here's another:

http://www.npr.org/2010/12/29/132407384/whats-a-mental-disor...

It's important to say that DSM-V (the new edition of the diagnostic manual) is being compiled in secret, contrary to the open nature of science, and demonstrating that the psychological community are circling the wagons against what is certain to be a storm of criticism once it's published (slated for May 2013).

One of the tidbits that has slipped out of the secret process is that grief over the loss of a loved one will qualify for a depression diagnosis, which will allow the prescribing of drugs to treat this new "mental illness."

Further reading: http://arachnoid.com/trouble_with_psychology

Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor by polshaw on Wednesday August 22, 2012 @02:59PM (#4418964)

    >Asperger’s syndrome... will be folded into a single broad diagnosis, autism spectrum disorder
^ FTA quoted as a source. It's not going anywhere, just re-labelling. There are definitely things behind AS, it's certainly not all just 'hullabaloo', even if a lot of cases might be.
Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor by lutusp on Wednesday August 22, 2012 @08:38PM (#4420335)
> It's not going anywhere, just re-labelling.

Not really. Two things are happening:

1. Asperger's is being dropped as a diagnosis.

2. ASD diagnostic criteria are being redefined with the specific aim of reducing the number of diagnoses, to avoid another epidemic of nonsense treatments of people who, apart from being intelligent, are otherwise normal.

Further reading: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/20/health/research/new-autism...

> There are definitely things behind AS ...

Yes, there certainly are. It's a gold mine for clinical psychology, because anyone to the right of the mean population I.Q. can be diagnosed using the present criteria, and because of this kind of abuse, it's being abandoned -- it's just too tempting to apply it to everyone. As one of its prominent critics has said, "It's not an evidence-based term."

Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor by philwelch on Wednesday August 22, 2012 @06:39PM (#4420006)
Didn't realize I'd ended up on Conspiracy Theory News.
Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor by lutusp on Wednesday August 22, 2012 @08:24PM (#4420283)
What? Psychologists have acknowledged what I said -- I didn't make it up. Psychologists now see that the Asperger's diagnosis epidemic had no basis in reality -- that's why Asperger's is being abandoned.

Further reading: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/03/health/03asperger.html?pag...

Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor by philwelch on Wednesday August 22, 2012 @09:38PM (#4420485)
It's effectively being reclassified as a form of autism, which is what neurologists have been calling it for years now.

You're being incoherent--why on earth would psychologists "abandon" a diagnosis that they "love" because it's "bread on their table"?

On second thought, don't bother answering--I already waste too much time jousting with conspiracy theorists on HN.

Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor by lutusp on Thursday August 23, 2012 @03:07AM (#4421252)
> It's effectively being reclassified as a form of autism

That's like saying astrology is being reclassified as a form of astronomy. Something like that happened, but we all know the outcome of that battle.

> why on earth would psychologists "abandon" a diagnosis that they "love" because it's "bread on their table"?

Because of public exposure. Because of articles like this one:

http://arachnoid.com/trouble_with_psychology

Psychologists realized their behavior was obviously and solely self-serving, even to non-specialists. So, just as with Recovered Memory Therapy, they called a halt to something that could only do them more harm.

> I already waste too much time jousting with conspiracy theorists on HN.

That only makes sense if psychologists are the conspiracy theorists, because it is psychologists who are demanding this change. Case in point -- Theodore Insel, sitting director of the NIMH, calls for the same change that I do:

http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=faulty-circ...

Quote: "In most areas of medicine, doctors have historically tried to glean something about the underlying cause of a patient’s illness before figuring out a treatment that addresses the source of the problem. When it came to mental or behavioral disorders in the past, however, no physical cause was detectable so the problem was long assumed by doctors to be solely “mental,” and psychological therapies followed suit.

Today scientific approaches based on modern biology, neuroscience and genomics are replacing nearly a century of purely psychological theories, yielding new approaches to the treatment of mental illnesses."

Sound familiar?

Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor by philwelch on Thursday August 23, 2012 @11:47AM (#4422984)
I think you have a point buried in there somewhere, but you're overstating it with so much hyperbole that you come across as a crank. Sort of like the LaRoucheites who used to accost people, panicked that Dick Cheney was going to nuke Iran.
Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor by lutusp on Friday August 24, 2012 @04:21AM (#4426736)
> you're overstating it with so much hyperbole that you come across as a crank.

Tell that to Dr. Insel, sitting director of the NIMH, who I quoted to make my point.

Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor by philwelch on Friday August 24, 2012 @05:17PM (#4429725)
Dr. Insel's quote wasn't the part that sounded crank-ish.
Re:Family trees: Tracing the world's ancestor by ktizo on Wednesday August 22, 2012 @12:36PM (#4418213)
Wasn't meaning it as intellectual, was more meaning it in as obsessed with pattern and order.