While I agree that this is a problem, I think a bigger problem is a simple matter of scale:
Amazon is huge, and many people buy things, but they don't split reviews and ratings by what kind of person is rating them. If they wanted to make an improvement, why not show me only ratings and reviews by people who are similar to me? They have tons of data about me and other people who use the service, so it should be possible for them to say "people like you rated this on average a 4, but everyone in the world rates it an average of 2.5."
That's much easier than having to read all the reviews and decide if the person is in my demographic or whether I agree with their review.
Netflix does. By cross referencing your likes and dislikes against those of your fellow Netflix members, the company is able to create a meta rating system, in which the score you see for a movie is your own. You see that score because that's how much Netflix thinks you'll like it, based on how similar people liked it.
This is the only good way of going about this method. The trick is, it's easy to do this with movies, but much more difficult with product ratings and the like. Maybe this is an opportunity for someone to build something on top of Facebook or Amazon.
It works exceptionally well. You just listen to the stream of incoming songs, you never pick songs yourself. After a good song you click like, after a mediocre song you keep listening, during a bad song you click skip. After a few days you will only get good songs! (with a few exceptions of course) It's like magic, i can't even count how many new bands i found through pandora without any effort.
Too bad it doesn't work outside US anymore. :(
Once you realize that people have different tastes and you know someone's preferences that is the obvious solution. Or is the process of crawling through that much statistical data that expensive that it can only be offered to paying subscribers?
I think Amazon's "Was this rating helpful (Yes/No)?" provides a good filter for ratings. A lot of mindlessly negative reviews get filtered out by the users who come along afterwards and rate the rating in their own self-interest.
Indeed, my suspicion is that organizational politics have more to do with the lack of a better rating system than any technical limitation.
The approach I use is to read 3 star ratings first before biasing myself with the more extreme ratings. I also check to see what else the reviewer has rated and if there's nothing there then I immediately dismiss the review.
N people rated this better than X movie, but less than Y movie.
Ranking movies can be easy. Show 5 movie posters instead of 5 stars or have an auto-complete field for this movie is up there with:.
I've often thought about some start-up ideas around relative ratings, and this book was the reason
[1] - http://danariely.com/
However, the type of rating mentioned in the OP and the type of rating on Netflix only seem to work in specific niches. I can't imagine how a website like Amazon would implement anything even close to what Goodfilms is doing.
When you first get on the website, you're asked to rate a number of products. The more you rate, the more accurate the solution becomes.
When it can couple your test with users having the same test, you know see these users ratings in priority for new products. You can even ask them why they disliked/liked something if they didn't write a review. Because their opinion matters to you now.
While words do express the point better, this rating system is a step in the right direction.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quis_custodiet_ipsos_custodes%3...
might in this context be paraphrased to "Who is rating the raters?" The hope in any online rating system is that enough people will come forward to rate something that you care about so that the people who have crazy opinions will be mere outliers among the majority of raters who share your well informed opinions. But how do you ever know that when you see an online rating of something that you haven't personally experienced?
Amazon has had star ratings for a long time. I largely ignore them. I read the reviews. For mathematics books (the thing I shop for the most on Amazon), I look for people writing reviews who have read other good mathematics books and who compare the book I don't know to books I do know. If an undergraduate student whines, "This book is really hard, and does a poor job of explaining the subject" while a mathematics professor says, "This book is more rigorous than most other treatments of the subject," I am likely to conclude that the book is a good book, ESPECIALLY if I can find comments about it being a good treatment of the subject on websites that review several titles at once, as for example websites that advise self-learners on how to study mathematics.
The problem with any commercial website with ratings (Amazon, Yelp, etc., etc.) is that there is HUGE incentive to game the ratings. Authors post bad ratings for books by other authors. The mother and sister and cousins of a restaurant owner post great ratings for their relative's restaurant, and lousy ratings for competing restaurants. I usually have no idea what bias enters into an online rating. So I try to look for the written descriptions of the good or service being sold, and I try to look for signals that the rater isn't just making things up and really knows what the competing offerings are like. When I am shopping for something, I ask my friends (via Facebook, often enough) for their personal recommendations of whatever I am shopping for. Online ratings are hopelessly broken, because of lack of authentication of the basis of knowledge of the raters, so minor details of dimensions of rating or of data display are of little consequence for improving online ratings.