Why did you pitch a 2% equity per month deal? You clearly don't have anything left to prove - you've already demonstrated your value and commitment to the project, not least by working unpaid.
I would negotiate hard for 33%. It's on your co-founders to give reasons why your share should be less - and here I would only accept hard contributions from them (e.g. cash they contributed to the business, additional months they spent on the concept), not soft contributions like "ideas" or "contacts".
Good luck!
But you are right that he should push for a response.
The other thing that seems to be missing from all these founder/first employee discussions is the level of influence over business direction and strategy. Some people may not want these responsibilities but others would relish the involvement.
Also, what's this company? Small aeroplane sounds exciting compared to HN's usual "next best todo app".
What does a late-coming co-founder expect then in terms of equity in a typical company? Clearly I don't deserve 1/3, but I'll be my salary will be restricted to whatever minimal amount the other founders and I can survive off of until the company grows up.
You deserve just as much motivation as they do for the sacrifice you're making and asking less than 1/3 is wasting your time. The worst they can do is fire you so you can make more money. That's when you start your own clone if you didn't sign a non-compete contract. And if you did, work for what you deserve elsewhere until it ends and then invest all your newly earned savings into building the better product.
Assuming significant work was done before OP joined, equal equity is not realistic (or fair). Also, are the others taking any money out (i'm guessing not?). There can of course be some value in ideas and traction (although AFAICT there isn't a lot unique nor is there a lot of traction). Moreover, i'm guessing most big decisions are not made by OP since he seems to be relegated to employee. Only if OP feels they are crucial and replaceable should he go for 1/3 (or more). From the little i know, 20%+ would be a good aim. If you think you can do better elsewhere (that is, you don't believe the business has unique strengths) then consider that.
It really is refreshing to see a non-web start-up mentioned here on hn. Well done to you guys and I hope the negotiations pan out for you.
Our current deal is that I'm given a monthly stipend for a few months while we process some sales and get a better idea of what the company is worth, so that I can be compensated accordingly.
I've been wary so far of considering myself a Co-Founder, since I took no part in the original idea or the funding for the company. From what this article is telling me though, I should absolutely be considering myself a co-founder.
If this is the case, how much should I push for in terms of compensation? Is 24% a reasonable number to go after considering the facts? I'm trying to look out for my best interests but honestly just have no idea what I'm doing. Any advice from HN would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks for the article.