News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My AI skeptic friends are all nuts by taurath on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @01:05AM (#44166480)
"Morally required to ... engage" with technologies that one disagrees with sounds fairly easily debunk-able to me. Everyone does what they can live with - being up close and personal, in empathy with humans who are negatively effected by a given technology, they can choose to do what they want.

Who knows, we might find out in a month that this shit we're doing is really unsafe and is a really bad idea, and doesn't even work ultimately for what we'd use it for. LLMs already lie and blackmail.

Re:My AI skeptic friends are all nuts by xpe on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @08:15AM (#44169142)
Three points. First, a moral code is a guidestar, principles to strive for, but not necessarily achieved.

Second. People can do what they want? To some degree. We live in a world of constraints. If you only do what you want, then you probably have changed what you want.

Third, here is what I mean by engage with a technology you disagree with: mindfully use it for your purposes. Here is an example. If one opposes urban development patterns that overemphasize private transit, does this mean boycotting all vehicles? Categorically refusing to rent a car? That would miss the point. Some of one’s best actions involve getting involved in local politics and advocacy groups. Hoping isolated individual action against entrenched interests will move the needle is wishful thinking. My point is simple: choose effective actions to achieve your goals. Many of these goals can only be achieved with collective action.

Re:My AI skeptic friends are all nuts by xpe on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @10:19AM (#44170438)
I’m outside the edit window, but I have one thing to add. To restate #5 differently: Banging one’s head against barely movable reality is not a wise plan; it is reactionary and probably a waste of your precious bodily fluids — I mean energy. On the other hand, focusing your efforts on calculated risks, even if they seem improbable, can be worthwhile, as long as you choose your battles.
Re:My AI skeptic friends are all nuts by taurath on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @05:13PM (#44174812)
Just responding to 5 here, as I think the rest is a capable examination but I think starts to move around the point I'm trying to make, that I disagree that one morally has to engage with AI. Its not just to "understand what you are facing" - that's a tactical choice, not a moral one. Its just not a moral imperative. Non-engagement can be a protest as well. Its one of the ways that the overton window maintains itself - if someone were to take the, to me, extreme view that AI/LLMs will within the next 5 years result in massive economic changes and eliminate much of society's need for artists or programmers, I choose not to engage with that view and give it light. I grew up around doomsayers and those who claim armageddon, and the arguments being made are often on similar ground. I think they're kooks who don't give a fuck about the consequences of their acceleration-ism, they're just chasing dollars.

Just as I don't need to understand the finer points of extreme bigotry to be opposed to it, we don't need to be experts on LLMs to be opposed to the well-heeled and breathless hype surrounding it, and choose to not engage with it.

Re:My AI skeptic friends are all nuts by xpe on Wednesday June 04, 2025 @03:30PM (#44184585)
In case it got lost from several comments higher in the chain, there is/was an "if" baked into my statement:

>> If one is motivated by ethics, I think it is morally required to find effective ways to engage to shape and nudge the future.

Put another way, the claim could be stated as: "if one is motivated by ethics, then one should pay attention to consequences". Yes, this assumes one accepts consequentialism to some degree, which isn't universally accepted nor easy to apply in practice. Still, I don't think many people (even those who are largely guided by deontology) completely reject paying attention to consequences.

Re:My AI skeptic friends are all nuts by xpe on Wednesday June 04, 2025 @03:37PM (#44184660)
> Just as I don't need to understand the finer points of extreme bigotry to be opposed to it, we don't need to be experts on LLMs to be opposed to the well-heeled and breathless hype surrounding it, and choose to not engage with it.

If by the last "it" you mean "the hype", then I agree.

But -- sorry if I'm repeating -- I don't agree with conflating the tools themselves with the hype about them. It is fine to not engage with the hype. But it is unethical to boycott LLM tooling itself when it could serve ethical purposes. For example, many proponents of AI safety recommend using AI capabilities to improve AI safety research.

This argument does rely on consequentialist reasoning, which certainly isn't the only ethical game in town. That said, I would find it curious (and probably worth unpacking / understanding) if one claimed deontological reasons for avoiding a particular tool, such as an LLM (i.e. for intrinsic reasons). To give an example, I can understand how some people might say that lying is intrinsically wrong (though I disagree). But I would have a hard time accepting that _using_ an LLM is intrinsically wrong. There would need to be deeper reasons given: correctness, energy usage, privacy, accuracy, the importance of using one's own mental faculties, or something plausible.