News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bohemians at the Gate? by altruios on Monday June 02, 2025 @12:06PM (#44160274)
A good argument. however to compare an AI model to a Xerox machine is reductive and not a sound metaphor...

It can not be treated just as a Xerox machine, but it can be treated as a Xerox machine that has within it all the copywritten works (that a user can inventively request combinations there within) which it has trained on (and saved in the form of weights/bias). In this case the AI model itself is the distribution of works under copyright. Encrypting/transforming copywritten works and transmitting it is a violation of copyright (afaik; ianal).

This is all to say, copyright - as it stands - needs heavy reform. I'm rather copyleft. Because all of this is vestigial nonsense from an age where printers from the 1800's setting the rules, and our thinking hasn't updated yet.

Re:Bohemians at the Gate? by parpfish on Monday June 02, 2025 @01:21PM (#44161068)
What would happen if you made a lossy image compression format derived from tons of scraped, copyrighted images.

There’s no generative ability, but anytime you compress/decompress your image the model uses weights and biases learned from copyrighted works.

Is that a violation?

Re:Bohemians at the Gate? by altruios on Monday June 02, 2025 @07:03PM (#44164231)
Nothing. and no:

Only distributing it to others is when copyright is an issue. Private translations/transformations are unenforceable. You can mark up a book you've bought as much as you want.

copyright makes no sense;