News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by dralley on Sunday June 01, 2025 @11:29PM (#44155614)
Strategic aviation is the least important and most dual-purpose of any of the three branches of the nuclear triad, and by this point Ukraine has ample justification for attacking it. It's an abstract concern in that sense. Destroying their entire strategic aviation forces would not meaningfully impact MAD.
Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by mmooss on Monday June 02, 2025 @01:44AM (#44156085)
> Destroying their entire strategic aviation forces would not meaningfully impact MAD.

The only person I see saying that is some random Internet commenter. I've always heard the opposite from professionals in the field, especially that any threat to capability is a threat to stability.

Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by geoka9 on Monday June 02, 2025 @02:15AM (#44156198)
I read somewhere that they still have their Tu-160s (at least). They have limited engine lifespan, so the Russians have been reluctant to use them for the terror sorties.
Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by ethbr1 on Monday June 02, 2025 @04:29PM (#44162704)
Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by noduerme on Monday June 02, 2025 @02:02AM (#44156152)
Well, consider North Korea. With them there's no "mutual" in the assured destruction to their side if they launched a nuke. How is that less a deterrent?
Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by mmooss on Monday June 02, 2025 @07:44PM (#44164599)
It's a good question and the answer is that the situation is unstable and dangerous. But I think you are approaching it backwards:

With almost every country in the world, the US has first strike capability - the US could wipe out the country in hours or less, and only a few countries have a second strike capability to deter the US.

That had long been true with NK, a very belligerent enemy. But in the last couple of decades NK added a small nuclear arsenal. It's not enough for a MAD relationship with the US, but they could threaten great harm to US allies South Korea and Japan - imagine nuking Seoul and Tokyo - and possibly land one on US territory. It wouldn't destroy the US, but losing San Francisco is a serious deterrent.

Did the addition of NK's nuclear arsenal stabilize the situation by creating more deterrent, or destabilize it by emboldening NK? It's complex:

One factor is that the US has sworn off use of nuclear weapons in conventional conflicts, even ones they are losing, and have strictly adhered to that policy, not even using small tactical nukes. The US has an even stronger motive - it establishes a global taboo against nuclear weapon use that nobody has violated yet. NK is very aware of it because US generals recommended using nuclear weapons in the Korean War and the president declined - that may seem like too close a call for NK, and don't assume that NK understands the US nearly as well as you do (if you are American); miscalculations like that are common on all sides in international relations.

So now that NK has nuclear weapons, does that make a conventional conflict into a nuclear one, destabillizing the situation? What if the US believes they need to use nuclear weapons to prevent NK from using them on Seoul or San Franciso?

On the other hand, NK's nukes may prevent a conventional war. NK saw what happened to Iraq - everyone did, and many realized that actual nuclear weapons were their only defense if the US was going to ignore international law and sovereignty and engage in 'regime change'.

Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by ponector on Monday June 02, 2025 @08:59AM (#44158370)
As I've heard from professionals, Kyiv will not stand more than three days against Russia in a full scale military conflict.

Strategic bombers make little sense, that's why everyone (even russians) are pushing for ballistic missiles instead. Strategic bombers used by Russia manly for terror with stockpile of soviet missiles.

Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by nradov on Monday June 02, 2025 @01:45PM (#44161286)
Strategic bombers still make a lot of sense if you need to, let's say, hold Iranian nuclear facilities at risk with large conventional bunker buster bombs. This is the primary mission that B-2 squadrons train for, and just the existence of that capability provides a lot of negotiating leverage. Of course it's also enormously expensive.
Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by ponector on Monday June 02, 2025 @03:56PM (#44162387)
B2 is much easier to intercept than ballistic missile. Also B2 has order of magnitude higher sticker price than ballistic missile. Good for bombing mujahedeen in the mountains and bad against someone with SAM. But for such bombing you don't need a strategic bomber, even frontline bomber could be enough.
Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by mmooss on Monday June 02, 2025 @07:28PM (#44164455)
> B2 is much easier to intercept than ballistic missile. Also B2 has order of magnitude higher sticker price than ballistic missile. Good for bombing mujahedeen in the mountains and bad against someone with SAM.

Where do people get these things? The B2 is awful for bombing low-tech insurgent forces - far too expensive to operate. Its whole purpose is defeating SAMs in particular and the best defenses in the world.

Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by hollerith on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @02:04PM (#44172819)
And the Pentagon likes the B-2 so much that they've developed a successor, the B-21:

"By September 2024, three test aircraft were in service: one performing one or two flight tests per week, and the others involved in ground tests."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_Grumman_B-21_Raider#F....

Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by mmooss on Wednesday June 04, 2025 @04:51PM (#44185382)
Eventually you need new a new plane; that doesn't mean the old one is a failure.

The US has only ~20 B-2s, to go with ~60 B-52s (originally built in the 1950s), and ~40 B-1Bs (~1980s tech). Only the B-2 could survive war with a peer, afaik; that was fine after the Cold War when there was no peer threat but now that China is a near-peer threat, the US needs many more bombers capable in a peer conflict and the B-2 production line was shut down decades ago (production was discontinued when the Cold War ended). They plan to build the B-21 in much larger numbers.

Also, the B-21 was built for conflict with China, where distances are much greater than in Europe.

Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by hollerith on Thursday June 05, 2025 @08:19AM (#44190919)
Oh, I wasn't being sarcastic: I was trying to convey that B-2 has been a great success (at least in the eyes of the Pentagon). The B-21 looks almost exactly like the B-2 (but is half the size / weight).
Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by nradov on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @01:53PM (#44172702)
Nah. Conventionally armed ballistic missiles or small strike aircraft aren't effective against deeply buried hardened bunkers, like Iranian or North Korean uranium refinement facilities. Only something like a B-2 carrying a GBU-57 will be effective for holding such targets at risk. This is considered a strategic imperative so cost is irrelevant.
Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by roncesvalles on Monday June 02, 2025 @02:31PM (#44161646)
Bombers don't make sense because they are big, lumbering targets for SAM systems. The B-2 is an exception because it is stealth and flies very high.
Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by slt2021 on Monday June 02, 2025 @02:39PM (#44161726)
B-2 is not stealth, its just low visibility in radio to the ground based radars.

It is very visible from the top, esp to aerial recon that use other signals in addition to radar signature

Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by mmooss on Monday June 02, 2025 @07:25PM (#44164430)
It is in fact stealth. Look up any information on it and it will tell you, it's a stealth bomber. Its primary capability is defeating enemy air defenses and holding their most valuable assets at risk.
Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by mmooss on Monday June 02, 2025 @07:24PM (#44164419)
So where do you get information? From people who are always right? Where are they? Are you one of them - if not, why should I listen to you?
Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by jacquesm on Monday June 02, 2025 @07:47PM (#44164619)
Or to you...
Re:'Russian bombers are burning en masse' by mmooss on Monday June 02, 2025 @07:55PM (#44164681)
Right. I'm repeating what actual experts say - including settled, consensus conclusions from decades of expertise. I'm not doing personal hot takes and if I did, they should be ignored. I'm not even posting expert hot takes, which also aren't so valuable (but much more valuable than my own).

I responded to this comment: "Destroying their entire strategic aviation forces would not meaningfully impact MAD."